Comparing lidar analysis and field documentation in archaeological surveys: feature recognition, quantification, and land-use modeling with the Small Cycladic Islands Project
Abstract
Over six field seasons (2019–2024), the Small Cycladic Islands Project (SCIP) has conducted systematic pedestrian surveys of 87 uninhabited islands across the Cycladic archipelago. In 2022 and 2023, SCIP acquired lidar data over 97 currently uninhabited islands in the Cyclades, working with the Thessaloniki-based company Aerophoto. The goals of this work were several: (1) to supplement and expand our knowledge of areas already surveyed by SCIP (2019–2021), many of which are heavily obscured by vegetation cover; (2) as a precursor and guide to our own pedestrian survey work in 2022–2024, especially in large islands that could not be surveyed at the same level of intensity as smaller ones; (3) to supplement investigations of other islands that are well known and have been surveyed by other projects using other methods (Delos, Rheneia, and Despotiko); and (4) to cover areas where it is not possible for the project to carry out pedestrian survey work, due to issues of accessibility, size, or other constraints (Gyaros and Antimilos).
References
Athanasoulis, D., A.R. Knodell, Ž. Tankosić, Z. Papadopoulou, M. Sigala, C. Diamanti, Y. Kourayos and A. Papadimitriou 2021. The Small Cycladic Islands Project (2019–2020): a comparative survey of uninhabited landscapes near Paros and Antiparos, Greece. Antiquity 95 (380): e12, 1–9.
Bevan, A., J. Conolly, S. Colledge, C. Frederick, C. Palmer, R. Siddall and A. Stellatou 2012. The longterm ecology of agricultural terraces and enclosed fields from Antikythera, Greece. Human Ecology 41: 255–272.
Brown, A., D. Fallu, K. Walsh, S. Cucchiaro: Tarolli: Zhao, B. Pears, K. Van Oost, L. Snape and A. Lang 2020a. Ending the Cinderella status of terraces and lynchets in Europe: the geomorphology of agricultural terraces and implications for ecosystem services and climate adaptation. Geomorphology 379: 107579.
Brown, A., K. Walsh, D. Fallu, S. Cucchiaro and P. Tarolli 2020b. European agricultural terraces and lynchets: From archaeological theory to heritage management. World Archaeology 52(4): 566–588.
Casana, J. 2021. Rethinking the landscape: Emerging approaches to archaeological remote sensing. Annual Review of Anthropology 50(1): 167–186.
Cloke, C.F., A.R. Knodell, S. Fachard and K. Papangeli 2023. Diagnostic visibility and problems of quantification in survey assemblages: examples from the Mazi Archaeological Project (northwest Attica), in A, Meens, M. Nazou and W. van de Put (eds) Fields, Sherds, and Scholars: Recording and Interpreting Survey Ceramics: 31–44. Leiden: Sidestone Press.
Comer, D.C. and M. Harrower (eds) 2013. Mapping Archaeological Landscapes from Space, New York: Springer.
Forte, M. and S. Campana 2016. Digital Methods and Remote Sensing in Archaeology: Archaeology in the Age of Sensing. New York: Springer.
Foxhall, L. and H.A. Forbes 1982. Sitometreia: the role of grain as a staple food in Classical Antiquity. Chiron 12: 41–90.
Frederick, C.D. and A. Krahtopoulou 2000. Deconstructing agricultural terraces: Examining the influence of construction method on stratigraphy, dating and archaeological visibility, in P. Halstead and C. Frederick (eds) Landscape and land use in postglacial Greece: 79–94. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press.
Grammer, B., E. Draganits, M. Gretscher and U. Muss 2017. LiDAR-guided archaeological survey of a Mediterranean landscape: Lessons from the ancient Greek polis of Kolophon (Ionia, western Anatolia). Archaeological Prospection 24(4): 311–333.
Halstead: and V. Isaakidou 2020. Pioneer farming in earlier Neolithic Greece, in K. Gron, Lasse Sørensen and P. Rowley-Conwy (eds) Farmers at the Frontier: A Pan European Perspective on Neolithisation: 77–100. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Hope Simpson, R., J.A., Clark and P. Goldberg 2004. The two agricultural terraces chosen for excavation, in P.P. Betancourt, K. Davaras and R. Hope Simpson (eds) Pseira IX: The Pseira Inland Survey. Part 2: The Intensive Survey: 251–256. Philadelphia: The Institute of Aegean Prehistory Academic Press.
Kiel, M. 2007. The smaller Aegean islands in the 16th–18th centuries according to Ottoman administrative documents. Between Venice and Istanbul: Colonial Landscapes in Early Modern Greece (Hesperia Supplement 40): 35–54. Princeton: American School of Classical Studies at Athens.
Knodell, A.R. 2025. Comparison and connections in the archaeology of small islands in Greece. Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology 38 : 79–110.
Knodell, A.R. D. Athanasoulis, Ž. Tankosić, J.F. Cherry, T.K. Garonis, E.I. Levine, D. Nenova and H.Ç. Öztürk 2022. An island archaeology of uninhabited landscapes: offshore islets near Paros, Greece (the Small Cycladic Islands Project). Journal of Island and Coastal Archaeology 17: 475–511.
Knodell, A.R., D. Athanasoulis, J.F. Cherry, M. Giannakopoulou, E.I. Levine, D. Nenova, H.Ç. Öztürk and Z. Papadopoulou 2025. A regional survey of the uninhabited islands of the western Cyclades: the Small Cycladic Islands Project 2021– 2022. Hesperia 94(4): 619–717.
Knodell, A.R., T.C. Wilkinson, T.P. Leppard and H.A. Orengo 2023. Survey archaeology in the Mediterranean world: regional traditions and contributions to long-term history. Journal of Archaeological Research 31: 263–329.
Kokalj, Ž. and M. Somrak 2019. Why not a single image? Combining visualizations to facilitate fieldwork and on-screen mapping. Remote Sensing 11: 747.
Krahtopoulou, A. and C. Frederick 2008. The stratigraphic implications of long-term terrace agriculture in dynamic landscapes: polycyclic terracing from Kythera Island, Greece. Geoarchaeology 23(4): 550–585.
Levine, E.I., H.Ç. Öztürk, A.R. Knodell, D. Nenova, J.F. Cherry, D. Athanasoulis, Z. Papadopoulou and Ž. Tankosić. Forthcoming. An island through time: surface survey and selective occupation on Strongylo (Antiparos), in E. Angliker and L. de Angelo Laky (eds) Small Island Resilience and Vulnerability, Society and Ecology in Island and Coastal Archaeology. University Press of Florida.
Lozić, E. and B. Štular 2021. Documentation of archaeology-specific workflow for airborne LiDAR data processing. Geosciences 11: 26.
Masini, N., F.T. Gizzi, M. Biscione, V. Fundone, M. Sedile, M. Sileo, A. Pecci, B. Lacovara and R. Lasaponara 2018. Medieval archaeology under the canopy with LiDAR. The (re)discovery of a medieval fortified settlement in southern Italy. Remote Sensing 10(10): 1598.
Parcak, S.H. 2009. Satellite Remote Sensing for Archaeology. London: Routledge.
Price, S. and L. Nixon 2005. Ancient Greek agricultural terraces: evidence from texts and archaeological survey. American Journal of Archaeology 109(4): 665–694.
Rom, J., F. Haas, M. Stark, F. Dremel, M. Becht, K. Kopetzky, C. Schwall, M. Wimmer, N. Pfeifer, M. Mardini and H. Genz 2020. Between land and sea: an airborne lidar field survey to detect ancient sites in the Chekka Region/Lebanon using spatial analyses. Open Archaeology 6(1): 248–268.
Rosenstein, N. 2008. Aristocrats and agriculture in the Middle and Late Republic. Journal of Roman Studies 98: 1–26.
Srivastava, A., T. Kinnaird, C. Sevara, J.A. Holcomb and S. Turner 2023. Dating agricultural terraces in the Mediterranean using luminescence: recent progress and challenges. Land 12(3): 716.
Štular, B., S. Eichert and E. Lozić 2021. Airborne LiDAR point cloud processing for archaeology: pipeline and QGIS toolbox. Remote Sensing 13: 3225.
Turner, S., T. Kinniard, G. Varinlioǧlu, T.E. Ȿerifoǧlu, E. Koparal, V. Demirciler, D. Athanasoulis, K. Ødegård, J. Crow, M. Johnson, J. Bolòs, J.C. Sánchez- Pardo, F. Carrer, D. Sanderson and A. Turner 2021. Agricultural terraces in the Mediterranean: Medieval intensification revealed by OSL profiling and dating. Antiquity 95(381): 773–790.
Vinci, G., F. Vanzani, A. Fontana and S. Campana 2024. LiDAR applications in archaeology: a systematic review. Archaeological Prospection.
Wiseman, J.R. and F. El-Baz (eds) 2007. Remote Sensing in Archaeology. New York: Springer.
Zakšek, K., K. Oštir and Ž. Kokalj 2011. Sky-view factor as a relief visualization technique. Remote Sensing 3(2): 398–415.
