Thracology and Nationalism in Bulgaria. Deconstructing Contemporaneous Historical and Archaeological Representations
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32028/exnovo.v2i0.391Keywords:
ethnicizing discourses, Bulgarian academia, thracology, nationalist continuumAbstract
It is now widely acknowledged that Bulgarian academic discourses of the country’s so-called communist era (1945-1989) were heavily politicized with the aim of nationalizing and ethnicizing the history of the Bulgarian people. This communist era phenomenon subscribes to a chronologically vaster process of nationalist continuum recognized to have spanned from the middle-end of the nineteenth century to at least the early 1990s. Despite this trend, Bulgarian academics, especially in the field of archaeology, have more recently presented their post-communist, transition period disciplines as ideology-free, objective, scientific research.
In this paper, we provide examples of recent theoretical developments and interpretations in the sub-field of thracology – studies of ancient Thracian culture – that indicate that this claim to objectivity is unfounded. Based on the examples provided we argue that not only have Bulgarian academic discourses in the fields in question not severed with the ethnicizing practices of the so-called nationalist continuum of the pre-communist and communist eras, but they are now flourishing on the nationalist foundation of the preceding century and a half. As such discourses are reproduced unquestioningly in specialized publications, their influence on right wing populism is incontestable as they provide the latter, wittingly or not, with the scientific authority it needs to justify its ethnicizing of “historical” tenets of racial and social discrimination.
References
ANGELOV, D., 1971. The Formation of the Bulgarian Nation, Sofia: Nauka i izkustvo (in Bulgarian, summary in English).
ANGELOV, D., 1984. Развитие и постижения на българската археология (1944-1984) [Development and achievements of Bulgarian archaeology (1944-1984)]. Archaeology (Sofia) 4: 1-8.
APARICIO RESCO P., 2016. Archaeology and Neoliberalism. Madrid: JAS Arqueologia.
ATKINSON J.A., I. BANKS & J. O'SULLIVAN (eds.), 1996. Nationalism and Archaeology - Scottish Archaeological Forum. Glasgow: Cruithne Press.
BAILEY, D. W., 1998. Bulgarian archaeology - Ideology, sociopolitics and the exotic, in: L. MESKELL (ed.), Archaeology Under Fire. Nationalism, politics and heritage in the Eastern Mediterranean and Middle East. London and New York: Routledge, 87-110.
BOURDIEU, P. 1998. L'essence du néolibéralisme. Le Monde Diplomatique (March 1998): 3.
BÜCHSENSCHÜTZ, U., 1996. Minderheiten Politik in Bulgarien. Die Politik der Bulgarischen Kommunistischen Partei gegenüber den Juden, Roma, Pomaken und Türken 1944 bis 1989, Berlin: Freien Universität.
CRAMPTON, R. J., 2007. Bulgaria, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
CURTONI, R. P., & G. POLITIS, 2006. Race and racism in South American archaeology, World Archaeology 38(1): 93-108. https://doi.org/10.1080/00438240500510080
DANKOVA, R., 2006. Казанлък и традициите на Българския принос в учението за ноосферата [Kazanlŭk and the traditions of the Bulgarian contribution in the teaching about the noosphere]. Проблеми и изследвания на тракийската култура I: 153-172.
DASKALOV, R., 2004. The Making of a Nation in the Balkans: Historiography of the Bulgarian Revival. Budapest - New York: CEU Press.
DETREZ, R., 2006. Historical Dictionary of Bulgaria (2nd ed.) Historical Dictionaries of Europe 46. Lanham (MD): The Scarecrow Press, Inc.
DIAZ-ANDREU M. & T. CHAMPION (eds.), 1996. Nationalism and Archaeology in Europe. London: Routledge Library Editions.
ENGSTRÖM, J., 2009. Democratisation and the Prevention of Violent Conflict: Lessons Learned from Bulgaria and Macedonia. Farnham: Ashgate.
FINE, J. V. A. JR., 1983. The Early Medieval Balkans: A Critical Survey from the Sixth to the Late Twelfth Century. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
FINE, J. V. A. JR., 1987. The Late Medieval Balkans: A Critical Survey from the Late Twelfth Century to the Ottoman Conquest. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
FAWCETT, C. & P. L. KOHL (eds.), 1995. Nationalism, politics, and the practice of archaeology, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
FOL, A., 2000. Ethnosness. Seminarium Thracicum 4: 31-48 (in Bulgarian, summary in English).
FOL, A., K. YORDANOV (JORDANOV) & K. POROZHANOV, 2002. Thirtieth anniversary of the Institute of Thracology at the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. Thracia 15: 27-42.
FOL, V., 2015. L'apport de la thracologie, in: J.-L. MARTINEZ, A. BARALIS, N. MATHIEUX, T. STOYANOV & M. TONKOVA (eds.), L'épopée des rois thraces: Des guerres médiques aux invasions celtes 479-278 av. J.-C.
découvertes archéologiques en Bulgarie [exposition, Paris, Musée du Louvre, 16 avril - 20 juillet 2015]. Paris: Somogy, 360-361.
FOTEV, G., 1996. Total Crisis and the Reorganization of Society, in: J. COENEN-HUTHER (ed.), Bulgaria at the Crossroads. New-York: Nova Science Publishers, Inc., 11-32.
FRUSETTA, J. & A. GLONT, 2009. Interwar fascism and the post-1989 radical right: Ideology, opportunism and historical legacy in Bulgaria and Romania. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 42(4): 551-571. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.postcomstud.2009.10.001
GERGOVA, D., 1986. ХIII конгрес на БКП и българската археологическа наука [13th Congress of the Bulgarian Communist Party and Bulgarian archaeological science]. Arheologiia (Sofia) 4: 1-4.
GERGOVA, D., 2001. Тракийска археология [Thracian archaeology], in: Състояние и проблеми на методиката и методологията на българската археология [The actual state and problems of the methods and methodology of Bulgarian archaeology]. Arheologiia (Sofia) 3-4:105-108.
GEORGIEVA, I., 1974. Sur certaines influences thraces dans la culture spirituelle du people bulgare. Thracia 2: 213-219.
GLOVER, I. G., 2016. Some national, regional, and Political Uses of Archaeology in East and Southeast Asia, in: M. T. STARK (ed.), Archaeology of Asia. Blackwell Studies in Global Archaeology. Malden, Oxford: Blckwell Publishing, 17-36. https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470774670.ch2
GORI, M. & M. IVANOVA (ed.), 2017. Balkan Dialogues - Negotiating Identity between Prehistory and the Present. London & New-York: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315673875
GOTSEV, A., 2001. Тракийска археология [Thracian archaeology], in: Българската археология през последното десетилетие на XX век [Bulgarian archaeology during the last decade of the twentieth century]. Arheologiia (Sofia) 3-4: 88-91.
GRAVES-BROWN, P., JONES, S. & C. GAMBLE, 1996. Cultural Identity and Archaeology: The Construction of European Communities. London: Routledge.
Hadzhinikolov, V., 1991. Theoretical Problems of Ethnography. Sofia: BAN (in Bulgarian, summary in English).
HAMILAKIS Y., 2007. The Nation and its Ruins - Antiquity, Archaeology and National Imagination in Greece, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
HARVEY, F. P., 2000. Primordialism, Evolutionary Theory and Ethnic Violence in the Balkans: Opportunities and Constraints for Theory and Policy. Canadian Journal of Political Science 33(1): 37-65. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0008423900000032
JIVKOV, T. I., 1994. The Ethnic Syndrome. Sofia: Alja (in Bulgarian, summary in English).
KACHAUNOV, S. & K. SIMEONOVA, 1979. Social studies of science in Bulgaria. Social Studies of Science 9(1): 91-99. https://doi.org/10.1177/030631277900900105
KARACHANAK, S., V. CAROSSA, D. NESHEVA, A. OLIVIERI, M. PALA, et al., 2012. Bulgarians vs the other European populations: a mitochondrial DNA perspective. International Journal of Legal Medicine 126: 497-503. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-011-0589-y
KARACHANAK S., V. GRUGNI, S. FORNARINO, D. NESHEVA, N. AL-ZAHERY, et al., 2013. Y-chromosome diversity in modern Bulgarians: New clues about their ancestry. PLoS ONE 8(3): 1-8. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0056779
KATSIKAS, S., 2012. Negotiating Diplomacy in the New Europe: Foreign Policy in Post-Communist Bulgaria, London - New York: I. B. Tauris. https://doi.org/10.5040/9780755620470
KOHL P. L. & C. P. FAWCETT (eds.), 1995. Nationalism, Politics, and the Practice of Archaeology. Cambridge, New York: Cambridge University Press.
KRASTEVA, A. (ED.), 1998. Общности и идентичности в България [Communities and Identities in Bulgaria]. Sofia: Petekston.
KRASTEVA, A., 2016. The post-communist rise of national populism: Bulgarian paradoxes, in: G. LAZARIDIS, G. CAMPANI & A. BENVENISTE (eds.), The Rise of the Far Right in Europe: Populist Shifts and 'Othering'. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 161-200. https://doi.org/10.1057/978-1-137-55679-0_7
MARINOV, T., 2010. La question macédonienne de 1944 à nos jours. Communisme et nationalisme dans les Balkans. Paris: L'Harmattan.
MARINOV, T., 2016. Nos ancêtres les Thraces: Usages idéologiques de l'Antiquité en Europe du Sud-Est. Paris: L'Harmattan.
MARTINEZ, J.-L., A. BARALIS, N. MATHIEUX, T. STOYANOV & M. TONKOVA (eds.), 2015. L'épopée des rois thraces: Des guerres médiques aux invasions celtes 479-278 av. J.-C.; découvertes archéologiques en Bulgarie [exposition, Paris, Musée du Louvre, 16 avril - 20 juillet 2015]. Paris: Somogy.
MEININGER, T. A., 1987. The Formation of a Nationalist Bulgarian Intelligentsia, 1835-1878. New York - London: Garland Publishing Inc.
MESKELL, L., 1998. Archaeology Under Fire - Nationalism, Politics and Heritage in the Eastern Mediterranean. Milton Park: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203259320
MIHAILOV, G. 2015 [1972]. Траките [The Thracians]. Sofia: New Bulgarian University.
MIJATEV, K., 1959. Петдесет години българска археология [Fifty years Bulgarian archaeology]. Arheologiia (Sofia) 3-4: 3-11.
MIKOV, V. (1943). Произход на надгробните могили в България [Origin of the funerary mounds in Bulgaria]. Annual of the National Museum: 16-31.
MILLER, M. L., 1975. Bulgaria during the Second World War. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
MINKOV, I. S., 2011. Ethnoses and Globalization Communities: Ethnic Communities in Bulgaria during the National Age and the Process of Globalization. Sofia: Tip-top Press (in Bulgarian, summary in English).
MITSEVA, E., 2001. Арменците в България - култура и идентичност [The Armenians in Bulgaria - culture and identity]. Sofia: IMIR.
NIKOLOV, V., 2001. Праистория [Prehistory], in: Българската археология през последното десетилетие на ХХ век [Bulgarian archaeology during the last decade of the twentieth century]. Arheologiia (Sofia) 3-4: 84-87.
OVČARIOM D. & R. BOGOMIROVA, 2001. 80 years Bulgarian Archaeological Institute. Arheologiia (Sofia) 3-4: 5-15 (in Bulgarian, summary in English).
ÖZDOǦAN, M., 1998. Ideology and Archaeology in Turkey, in: L. MESKELL (ed.), Archaeology under Fire: Nationalism, Politics and Heritage in the Eastern Mediterranean and Middle East. Milton Park: Routledge, 11-123.
ÖZDOǦAN, M., 2017. Neolithic assemblages and spatial boundaries as exemplified through the Neolithic of Northwestern Turkey, in: M. GORI & M. IVANOVA, Balkan Dialogues - Negociating Identity between Prehistory and the Present. London & New-York: Routledge: 197-212. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315673875-11
PALAVESTRA, A. & S. BABIĆ, 2016. False analogy: Transfer of theories and methods in archaeology (the case of Serbia). European Journal of Archaeology 19(2): 316-334. https://doi.org/10.1080/14619571.2016.1147314
POPOV, V., 1983. La thracologie Durant la période 1980-1990: problèmes et perspectives. Pulpudeva 4: 7- 15.
POPOV, D., 1999. Тракология [Thracology]. Sofia: Lik.
POPOV, D., 2007. Тракийските царе. Поведение и превъплъщения [The Thracian Kings. Behavior and Reincarnations]. Sofia: Lik.
POROJANOV, K., 2000. State Organization and Civilization in Thrace and of the Thracians till mid-1st Mill. BC, Seminarium Thracicum 4: 9-18 (in Bulgarian, summary in English).
POROJANOV, K., 2012. The Thracian Civilization in the Beginnings of two Continents and on the Coasts of three Seas (in ten studies). Thracia Antiqua 11 (in Bulgarian, summary in English).
POROJANOV, K., 2017a. Empire and Polis in Thrace, Hellas and Rome (in the Context of the States from the Eastern Mediterranean in the 6th/5th century BC - 1st/2nd Century AD). Thracia 22: 11-25.
POROJANOV, K. 2017b. Polis and Ethnos along the Western Black Sea Coast: 3rd Century BC - 1st Century AD. Thracia 22: 27-33.
PREŠLENOV, H., 1995. Бележити изследователи на античната археология в България - творчески биографии [Illustrious researchers of Bulgaria's ancient archaeology - biographies of their work], Arheologiia (Sofia) 1: 16-22.
PUNDEFF, M., 1969. Bulgarian Nationalism, in: P. F. SUGAR & I. J. LEDERER (eds.), Nationalism in Eastern Europe. Seattle and London: University of Washington Press, 93-165.
RAŠEV, R., 2007. 60 години от обединяването на Народния археологически музей и Българския археологически институт [60 years of the unification of the National Museum of Archaeology and the Bulgarian Archaeological Isntitute]. Arheologiia (Sofia) 1-4: 229-231.
ROUMENTCHEVA, S., 2015. Les Thraces à Paris, in: J. L. MARTINEZ, A. BARALIS, N. MATHIEUX, T. STOYANOV & M. TONKOVA (eds.), L'épopée des rois thraces: Des guerres médiques aux invasions celtes 479-278 av. J.-C.
découvertes archéologiques en Bulgarie [exposition, Paris, Musée du Louvre, 16 avril - 20 juillet 2015]. Paris: Somogy, 362-363.
SEMINARIUM THRACICUM 1985: Seminarium Thracicum 1, Sofia: Institute of Thracology, Bulgarian Academy of Science.
SILVERMAN, H. & W. H. ISBELL (eds.), 2008. Handbook of South American Archaeology. New-York: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-0-387-74907-5
SPIRIDONOV, T., 1991. The Thracian Ethnos: Problems of its Formation and Development, Sofia: Bulgarian Academy of Science, Institute for Thracology (in Bulgarian, summary in English).
SPIROVA, M., 2007. Political Parties in Post-Communist Societies: Formation, Persistence, and Change. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230605664
STANTCHEVA, M., 1981. За късната тракийска култура [About late Thracian culture], in: V. TŬPKOVA-ZAIMOVA & K. Y. YORDANOV (eds.), Проблеми на културното наследство [Problems of cultural heritage]. Sofia: Institute of Thracology, 25-45.
SUGAR, P. F. & I. J. LEDERER (eds.), 1969. Nationalism in Eastern Europe. Seattle and London: University of Washington Press.
TEODOROV, E., 1972. Altthrakische Erbschaft in der bulgarischen Folklore, Thracia 1: 315- 326.
TEODOROV, E., 1999 [1972]. Old Thracian Heritage in the Bulgarian Folklore. Sofia: Akademitchno Izdatelstvo "Prof. Marin Drinov". (in Bulgarian, summary in English)
TODOROVA, M., 1992. 'Historiography of the countries of Eastern Europe: Bulgaria', American Historical Review 97(4): 1105-1117. https://doi.org/10.2307/2165495
TODOROVA, M., 1995. The Course and Discourses of Bulgarian Nationalism, in: P. F. SUGAR. (ed.), Eastern European Nationalism in the Twentieth Century. Washington (DC): The American University Press, 55-102.
VAGALINSKI, L., 2001. Антична археология [Archaeology of Antiquity], in: Състояние и проблеми на методиката и методологията на българската археология [The current state and problems of the methods and methodology of Bulgarian archaeology]. Arheologiia (Sofia) 3-4: 108-111.
VASSEVA, V., 1998. Власи [Vlakhs], in: A. KRASTEVA (ed.), Общности и идентичности в България [Communities and Identities in Bulgaria]. Sofia: Petekston, 170-189.
VASSILEV, R., 2003. The "Third-Worldization" of a "Second-World" nation: De-development in post-communist Bulgaria. New Political Science 25(1): 99-112. https://doi.org/10.1080/0739314032000077400
VELKOV V., 1993. Archaeology in Bulgaria. Antiquity 67(254): 125-129. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003598X00045166
VENEDIKOV, I., 1981. Българската култура и древността [Bulgarian culture and antiquity], in: V. TŬPKOVA-ZAIMOVA & K. Y. YORDANOV (eds.), Проблеми на културното наследство [Problems of cultural heritage]. Sofia: Institute of Thracology, 5-24.
YOROUKOVA (YOUROUKOVA), Y., 2001. A remarkable jubilee - the 80th anniversary of the Institute of Archaeology. Arheologiia (Sofia) 1: 7-15. (in Bulgarian, summary in English)
ZAREV, K., 2009. Празници на тракийската култура в Казанлък - традиция и съвременност [Festivities of Thracian culture in Kazanlŭk - tradition and contemporaneity]. Проблеми и изследвания на тракийската култура IV: 5-6.
ZLATKOVA, M., 2009. Богдан Филов. Живот между науката и политикатa [Bogdan Filov. A Life between Science and Politics]. Sofia: Altea.
ZORZIN, N., 2016. New Managerial Strategies in British Commercial Archaeology, in: P. APARICIO RESCO (ed.), Archaeology and Neoliberalism. JAS Arqueología S.L.U (December 2016): Madrid, 297-325.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
