Qumran, Unchecked Parallelomania, and Pseudonymity in Academic Publication
Keywords:
Qumran, Dead Sea ScrollsAbstract
This monograph has a promising premise – which is to situate Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls within the socio-political and cultural milieu of the Graeco-Roman world – but a deeply flawed execution. Its many problems can be summed up into four main points: 1) methodological and interpretative shortcomings; 2) unchecked parallelomania; 3) factual errors; and 4) the use of pseudonymity in academic publication. In the following pages, I will explore each of these issues in some detail. But first, I start with a brief overview of Kenneth Silver’s main arguments and hypothesis.
References
Y. Adler, The Archaeology of Purity. Archaeological Evidence for the Observance of Ritual Purity in Eretz-Israel from the Hasmonean Period until the End of the Talmudic Era (164 BCE – 400 CE) (PhD diss., Bar-Ilan University 2011) [Hebrew]
Y. Adler, Tosefta Shabbat 1:14 – »Come and See the Extent to Which Purity Had Spread«. An Archaeological Perspective on the Historical Background to a Late Tannaitic Passage, in: S. Fine – A. Koller (eds.), Talmuda De-Eretz Israel: Archaeology and the Rabbis in Late Antique Palestine, Studia Judaica 73 (Berlin 2014) 63–82
P. S. Alexander – G. Vermes, Qumran Cave 4. XIX. Serekh ha-Yahad and Two Related Texts, DJD 26 (Oxford 1998)
P. Bar-Adon, Another Settlement of the Judean Desert Sect at Ein El-Ghuweir on the Shores of the Dead Sea, BASOR 227, 1977, 1–25
R. Bar-Nathan, Hasmonean and Herodian Palaces at Jericho. Final Reports of the 1973–1987 Excavations 3. The Pottery (Jerusalem 2002)
A. M. Berlin, Archaeological Sources for the History of Palestine: Between Large Forces: Palestine in the Hellenistic Period, BibAr 60, 1997, 2–51
A. M. Berlin, Hellenistic Period, in: S. Gitin (ed.), The Ancient Pottery of Israel and Its Neighbors from the Iron Age through the Hellenistic Period 2 (Jerusalem 2015) 629–671, 744–745
J. J. Collins, Beyond the Qumran Community: The Sectarian Movement of the Dead Sea Scrolls (Grand Rapids, MI 2010)
I. Eisenstadt, Qumran Pottery, in: Magen – Peleg 2018, 179–338
K. Galor, Qumran’s Plastered Pools: A New Perspective, in: J.-B. Humbert – J. Gunneweg (eds.), Khirbet Qumrân et ‘Aïn Feshkha 2. Études d’anthropologie, de physique et de chimie. Studies of Anthropology, Physics and Chemistry, NTOA 3 (Göttingen 2003) 291–320
H. Geva, Hellenistic Pottery from Areas W and X-2, in: H. Geva (ed.), Jewish Quarter Excavations in the Old City of Jerusalem 2. The Finds from Areas A, W and X-2 (Jerusalem 2003) 113–175
Y. M. Gillihan, Civic Ideology, Organization, and Law in the Rule Scrolls. A Comparative Study of the Covenanters’ Sect and Contemporary Voluntary Associations in Political Context, STDJ 97 (Leiden 2012)
H. H. Harrington, The Purity Texts, Companion to the Qumran Scrolls 5 (London 2004)
P. B. Hartog, Pesher and Hypomnema. A Comparison of Two Commentary Traditions from the Hellenistic-Roman Period, STDJ 121 (Leiden 2017)
C. Hempel, Who Is Making Dinner at Qumran? Journal of Theological Studies 63, 2012, 49–65
M. Hengel, Judaism and Hellenism. Studies in their Encounter in Palestine during the Early Hellenistic Period, 2 vols. (Philadelphia 1974)
M. Henze (ed.), A Companion to Biblical Interpretation in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI 2012)
P. Horden – N. Purcell, The Corrupting Sea. A Study of Mediterranean History (Oxford 2000)
J.-B. Humbert, Reconsideration of the Archaeological Interpretation of Qumran, in: J.-B. Humbert – J. Gunneweg (eds.), Khirbet Qumrân et ‘Aïn Feshkha 2. Études d’anthropologie, de physique et de chimie (Studies of Anthropology, Physics and Chemistry), NTOA 3 (Göttingen 2003) 419–440
J.-B. Humbert, Arguments en faveur d’une résidence pré-essénienne, in: J.-B. Humbert – J. Gunneweg (eds.), Khirbet Qumrân et ‘Aïn Feshkha 2. Études d’anthropologie, de physique et de chimie, Studies of Anthropology, Physics and Chemistry, NTOA 3 (Göttingen 2003) 467–482
J.-B. Humbert – A. Chambon – J. Młynarczyk, Khirbet Qumrân et Aïn Feshkha. Fouilles du P. Roland de Vaux, IIIA. L’archéologie de Qumrân, NTOA 5a (Göttingen 2016)
E. Lanciers, The Shrines of Hathor and Amenhotep in Western Thebes in the Ptolemaic Period, Ancient Society 44, 2014, 105–125
L. de Ligt – L. E. Tacoma (eds.), Migration and Mobility in the Early Roman Empire, Studies in Global Social History 23 – Studies in Global Migration History 7 (Leiden 2016)
M. Lönnqvist – K. Lönnqvist, Archaeology of the Hidden Qumran. The New Paradigm (Helsinki 2002)
M. Lönnqvist – K. Lönnqvist, Parallels to Be Seen: Manuscripts in Jars from Qumran and Egypt, in: A. Lange – E. Tov – M. Weigold (eds.), in association with B. H. Reynolds III, The Dead Sea Scrolls in Context. Integrating the Dead Sea Scrolls in the Study of Ancient Texts, Languages, and Cultures, 2 vols., Vetus Testamentum Suppl. 140 (Leiden 2011) 471–487
H. I. MacAdam, Remarks on Kenneth Silver’s Alexandria and Qumran (2017), Qumran Chronicle 25, 2017, 163–169
Y. Magen –Y. Peleg, Back to Qumran: Final Report 1993–2004, Judea and Samaria Publications 18 (Jerusalem 2018)
J. Magness, The Archaeology of Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls, Studies in the Dead Sea Scrolls and Related Literature (Grand Rapids, MI 2003)
J. Magness, Stone and Dung, Oil and Spit: Jewish Daily Life in the Time of Jesus (Grand Rapids, MI 2011)
I. Malkin, A Small Greek World. Networks in the Ancient Mediterranean, Greeks Overseas (Oxford 2011)
J. T. Milik, Le giarre dei manoscritti della grotto del mar morto e dell’Egitto Tolemaico, Biblica 31, 1950, 504–508
D. Mizzi, The Glass from Khirbet Qumran: What Does It Tell Us About the Qumran Community? in: C. Hempel (ed.), The Dead Sea Scrolls. Texts and Context, STDJ 90 (Leiden 2010) 99–198
D. Mizzi, Qumran Period I Reconsidered: An Evaluation of Several Competing Theories, DSD 22, 2015, 1–42
D. Mizzi, The Animal Bone Deposits at Qumran: An Unsolvable Riddle? Journal of Ancient Judaism 7, 2016, 51–70
J, Młynarczyk, Terracotta Oil Lamps from Qumran: The Typology, RB 120–121, 2013, 99–133
J. Młynarczyk, Qumran Terracotta Oil Lamps, in: Humbert et al. 2016, 447–521
M. Pitts – M. J. Versluys (eds.), Globalisation and the Roman World. World History, Connectivity and Material Culture (Cambridge 2017)
K. D. Politis, The Nabataean Cemetery at Khirbet Qazone, NEA 62, 1999, 128
K. D. Politis, The Discovery and Excavation of the Khirbet Qazone Cemetery and its Significance Relative to Qumrân, in: K. Galor – J.-B. Humbert – J. Zangenberg (eds.), Qumran, the Site of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Archaeological Interpretations and Debates, Proceedings of a Conference Held at Brown University, November 17–19, 2002, STDJ 57 (Leiden 2006) 213–219
R. Reich, Miqwaʾot (Jewish Ritual Baths) in the Second Temple, Mishnaic and Talmudic Periods (Jerusalem 2013) [Hebrew]
R. Reich, Some Notes on the Miqva’ot and Cisterns at Qumran, in: A. E. Killebrew – G. Faßbeck (eds.), Viewing Ancient Jewish Art and Archaeology. VeHinnei Rachel – Essays in Honor of Rachel Hachlili, Journal of the Study of Judaism Suppl. 172 (Leiden 2015) 414–424
V. Roudometof, Glocalization. A Critical Introduction (London 2016)
S. Sandmel, Parallelomania, Journal of Biblical Literature 81, 1962, 1–13
O. Shamir, Textiles and Garments from Qumran. Chalcolithic and Roman Period, in: J. Gunneweg – C. Greenblatt – A. Adriaens (eds.), Bio- and Material Cultures at Qumran, Papers from a COST Action G8 Working Group Meeting held in Jerusalem, Israel on 22–23 May 2005 (Stuttgart 2006) 285–296
O. Shamir – N. Sukenik, Qumran Textiles and the Garments of Qumran’s Inhabitants, DSD 18, 2011, 206–225
M. E. Smith, How Can Archaeologists Make Better Arguments? The SAA Archaeological Record 15/4, 2015, 18–23
S. H. Steckoll, Preliminary Excavation Report in the Qumran Cemetery, Revue de Qumran 6, 1968, 323–344
S. H. Steckoll, Marginal Notes on the Qumran Excavations, Revue de Qumran 7, 1969, 33–40
S. H. Steckoll, The Community of the Dead Sea Scrolls, AttCItRom 5, 1973–74, 199–244
J. Taylor, Pythagoreans and Essenes. Structural Parallels, Collection de la Revue des études juives 32 (Leuven 2005)
J. E. Taylor, The Essenes, the Scrolls, and the Dead Sea (Oxford 2012)
J. A. Teixeira da Silva, Are Pseudonyms Ethical in (Science) Publishing? Neuroskeptic as a Case Study, Science and Engineering Ethics 23, 2017, 1807–1810
K. Vandorpe, Archives and Dossiers, in: R. S. Bagnall (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Papyrology (Oxford 2011) 216–255
R. de Vaux, Fouille de Khirbet Qumrân. Rapport préliminaire, RB 60, 1953, 83–106
R. de Vaux, Fouilles de Khirbet Qumrân. Rapport préliminaire sur la deuxième campagne, RB 61, 1954, 206–236
R. de Vaux, La Poterie, in: D. Barthélemy – J. T. Milik, Qumran Cave I, DJD 1 (Oxford 1955) 8–17
R. de Vaux, Fouilles de Khirbet Qumrân. Rapport préliminaire sur les 3e, 4e, et 5e campagnes, RB 63, 1956, 533–577
R. de Vaux, Archéologie, in: M. Baillet – J. T. Milik – R. de Vaux, Les ›Petites Grottes‹ de Qumrân, DJD 3 (Oxford 1962) 3–36
R. de Vaux, Archaeology and the Dead Sea Scrolls, rev. ed. (London 1973)
R. de Vaux, Archéologie, in: R. de Vaux – J. T. Milik, Qumrân Grotte 4, DJD 6 (Oxford 1977) 3–22
K. Vlassopoulos, Greeks and Barbarians (Cambridge 2016)
I. C. Werrett, Ritual Purity and the Dead Sea Scrolls, STDJ 72 (Leiden 2007)
T. Whitmarsh (ed.), Local Knowledge and Microidentities in the Imperial Greek World, Greek Culture in the Roman World (Cambridge 2012)
B. Yuzefovsky, The Metal Finds, in: Magen – Peleg 2018, 387–402
B. Zissu, ›Qumran Type‹ Graves in Jerusalem: Archaeological Evidence of an Essene Community? DSD 5, 1998, 158–171
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Journal of Hellenistic Pottery and Material Culture
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
