Communication network of the Ararat Plain, Armenia. Geographical, economic, political dimensions (1st millennium BC – 1st millennium AD)
Keywords:
Armenia, Ararat Valley, Roadology, Trade routes, Artaxata, Methodology, Silk RoadAbstract
Ararat Valley – the largest plain of the Armenian Highlands, at least since the stage of Chalcolithic takes up the role of the economic and cultural centre of the mentioned region. This phenomenon was the naturally determined result of the climatic and orographic characteristics of the valley and particularly its communicative characteristics. The latter was mostly based on the river-lines of the valley itself, as well as the network of adjacent river drainages and the accessible mountain passes. In course of time these natural ‘channels’ had facilitated the formation of roads at the axis of South-North and East-West (Arax – Hrazdan – Akhurian – Arpa – Vorotan – Kotur; Aghstev – Kur – Aragvi; Euphrates and Tigris water drainages etc.). In these aspects the interconnection of the societies with those of the neighboring regions is proven by the corresponding archaeological materials, which confirm both the facts of import and export. The economic, social and other processes of the following centuries resulted in the development of stable communication routes of the highlands and their active operation. Since at least the beginning of the 1st millennium BC, along with the establishment of unitary statehood on the territory of the Armenian Highlands (Urartu), the system of trade routes develops greatly, with Ararat Valley as one of its most important hubs. This route system has been inherited and enlarged by Armenian kingdoms of the subsequent, Classical period (Ervandid, Artaxian, Arsacid). Since the 6th century BC the trade routes of Armenia, and particularly the Ararat Valley, are tightly integrated into the road networks of the Near East, Central Asia and the Eastern Mediterranean. Thus, the following routes went through Ararat Valley: roads leading to the North – to the Eastern shore of the Black Sea and the mountain passes of the Caucasus; roads leading to the East, South and West – Iran, Mesopotamia, Syria and Asia Minor. The constant and active exploitation of all the mentioned routes finds its reflection both in narrative sources, as well as archaeological and numismatic materials. The same sources confirm the fact that the communication routes of the valley were also incorporated into the network of the Great Silk Road since the 2nd century BC up to the late Middle Ages. The fact that five of the six capitals of Classical and Early Medieval Armenia (Armavir, Ervandashat, Artashat, Vagharshapat, Dvin) have been located in Ararat Valley is the clear illustration of the economic, communicational, cultural and at last political importance of this sub-region of the Armenian Highland. The contemporary methods of Roadology, basing on the complex research of the geographic, narrative, archaeological and other data, provide an opportunity of revealing the line of these routes, the dynamics of their exploitation, the role of the trading centres located along these routes, the details of import and export etc.
References
Abrahamyan, A. 1944. Anania Širakac‘u matenagrut‘yunə (Chronicles of Anania Shirakatsi). Yerevan: State Matenadaran Publications (in Armenian).
Abrahamyan, L., Kharatyan, Z. (eds) 1982. Eritasard gitnakanneri V gitažołov (V Conference of Young Scientists). Yerevan: Haykakan SSH GA hratarakč ‘ut‘yun (in Armenian).
Agathangelos. Hayoc‘ Patmut‘yun (History of Armenians) (Orig. text and Arm. transl. A. Ter-Ghevondyan). Yerevan: Yerevan University Press, 1983 (in Armenian).
Alishan, Gh. 1890. Ayrarat. Venice, San Lazzaro: San Lazzaro Abbey publ. (in Armenian).
Arriani Anabasis (Rus. transl. M.E. Sergeienko). Moscow – Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR, 1962 (in Russian).
Avagyan, A., Kinnaird, T., Lichtenberger, A., Sahakyan, L., Schreiber, T., Zardaryan, M.H. 2019. Evidence of an historical earthquake in Artaxata-Artashat in the Ararat Basin of Armenia. AMIT 50 (in press).
Avdalbekyan, T. 1969. Arak‘si hnadaryan hunə Araratyan daštum (Ancient course of Arax in the Ararat Plane), in: Sargsyan 1969: 80-101 (in Armenian).
Badalyan, M., Martirosyan-Olshansky, Ch., Bobokhyan, A. (eds) 2022. Covayin Hayastan. Uduri-Et‘iuni erkri hnagitakan žaṛangut‘yunǝ (Armenia Maritima: Archaeological Heritage of the Land Uduri-Etiuni). Yerevan: Publishing House of the Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography.
Badalyan, R., Chataigner, Ch., Harutyunyan, A. (eds) 2022. The Neolithic Settlement of Aknashen (Ararat Valley, Armenia). Excavation Seasons 2004-2015. Oxford: Archaeopress.
Baghdasaryan, A. 1974. Araratyan dašt (Ararat Plain), in: Hambardzumyan 1974: 700-701.
Berdnikov, I., Lipnina, E. (eds) 2018. Evrazija v kajnozoe. Stratigrafija, paleoékologija, kul’tury (Eurasia in Kaynozoe. Stratigraphy, Palaeoecology, Cultures), vol. 7. Irkutsk: Irkutsk State University.
Cassii Dionis Cocceiani Historia Romana. Libri LXIV-LXXX. (Rus. transl. and comment. A.V. Makhlayuk). Fontes Scripti Antiqui. Sankt-Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo Nestor-Istorija, 2011 (in Russian).
Dan, R. 2014. Inside the Empire: Some remarks on the Urartian and Achaemenid presence in the Autonomous Republic of Nakhchivan. Iran and the Caucasus 18/4: 327-344.
Evlia Çelebi. 1983. Kniga Putešestvij (Book of Travels), vol. 3 (Rus. transl., ed. A.D. Zheltyakov). Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).
Grigoryan, K.N., Orbeli, R.R. (eds) 1980. Žizn Artemija Araratskogo (Life of Artemii Araratskij). Leningrad: Nauka (in Russian).
Hakobyan, A., Bozoyan, A., Safrastyan, R. (eds) 2017(2018). Hayastanǝ ev Arevelyan k‘ristoneakan k‘ałak‘akrt‘ut‘yunǝ III (Armenia and Oriental Christian Civilization III). Yerevan: HH GAA ‘Gitut‘yun’ hratarakč‘ut‘yun.
Hambardzumyan, V. (ed.) 1974. Haykakan sovetakan hanragitaran, hator 1 (Armenian Soviet Encyclopaedia, vol. 1). Yerevan: Haykakan hanragitarani hratarakč‘ut‘yun.
Harutyunyan, B. (ed.) 1982. Širaki patmamšakut‘ayin žaṛangut‘yunǝ 2 (The Historical-Cultural Heritage of Shirak 2): 10-11. Gyumri. Haykakan SSH GA hratarakč‘utyun (in Armenian).
Hayastani azgayin atlas (National Atlas of Armenia) (ed. M. Vardanyan), volume I, Yerevan, 2007.
Herodotus. Istorija (History) (Rus. transl. G.A. Stratanovakij). Leningrad: Nauka, 1972 (in Russian).
Higuchi, T. (ed.) 1995. Silk Roadology 1. Nara: Research Center for Silk Roadology.
Higuchi, T., Izumi, T. (eds) 1994. Tombs A and C. Southeast Necropolis. Palmyra, Syria. Surveyed in 1990-1992 (Publications of Research Center for Silk Roadology 1). Nara: Research Center for Silk Roadology.
Hirth, F. 1885. China and Roman Orient. Leipzig – Munich – Shanghai – Hongkong: Georg Hirth, Kelly & Walsh.
Ivanovskij, A.A. 1911. Po Zakavkaz’ju: Arxeologičeskie nabljudenija i issledovanija 1893, 1894 i 1896 gg. (By Transcaucasus: Archaeological Survey and Explorations of 1893, 1894 and 1896). Materialy po Arxeologii Kavkaza 6: 33-61 (in Russian).
Karakhanyan, A., Sahakyan, L., Avagyan, A., Iordanidis, A., Atalyan, T. 2022. Tectonic impact on the Ararat Depression during the Late Neolithic: The example of the Aknashen settlement, in: Badalyan et al. 2022: 47-60.
Kleiss, W. 1977. Urartäische Plätze in Iran. AMI 10: 53-118.
Kleiss, W. (ed.) 1979. Bastam I. Ausgrabungen in den Urartäisch Anlagen 1972-1975 (Teheraner Forschungen 4). Berlin: Gebr. Mann Verlag.
Kleiss, W. 1988a. Die Architektur, in: Kleiss 1988b: 13-74.
Kleiss, W. (ed.) 1988b. Bastam II. Ausgrabungen in den Urartäisch Anlagen 1976-1978 (Teheraner Forschungen 5). Berlin: Gebr. Mann Verlag.
Kleiss, W., Kroll, S. 1978. Urartaische Platze und Anlagen des 2.-1. Jahrtausend v.Chr. in Iran. AMI 11: 27-71.
Kleiss, W., Kroll, S. 1979. Vermessene urartaische Plätze in Iran (West-Azerbaidjan) und Neufunde (Stand der Forschung 1978). AMI 12: 183-243.
Kleiss, W., Kroll, S. 2004. Archaeological surveys in Northwestern Iran, conducted by Wolfram Kleiss and Stephan Kroll (1967-1991). http://www.vaa.fak12.uni-muenchen.de/ lran/lran.html
Kroll, S. 2000. Nordwest-Iran in achaimenidischer Zeit. Zur Verbreitung der Classic Triangle Ware. AMIT 32: 131-138.
Manandyan, H. 1936. Hayastani glxavor čanaparhnerə əst Pevtingeryan k‘artezi (Main Roads of Armenia according Tabula Peutingeriana). Yerevan: Githrati tparan (in Armenian).
Manandyan, H.A. 1954. O torgovle i gorodax Armenii v svjazi s mirovoj torgovlej drevnix vremen (V v. do n.é. – XV v. n.é.) / (On the Trade and Cities of Armenia in the Context of World Trade of Ancient Times (5th century BC – 15th century AD)/). Yerevan: Izdatel’stvo Erevanskogo universiteta (in Russian).
Marro, C., Özfirat, A. 2003. Pre-Classical survey in Eastern Turkey. First preliminary report: The Ağrı Dağ (Mount Ararat) region. AnAn 11: 385-422.
Martirosyan, H.A. 1974. Argištixinili (Argishtikhinili) /(Arxeologičeskie pamjatniki Armenii 8. Urartskie pamjatniki I (Archaeological Monuments of Armenia 8. Urartian Sites I)/). Yerevan: Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk Armjanskoj SSR (in Russian).
Miller, K. 1916. Itineraria Romana. Römische Reisewege an der Hand der Tabula Peutingeriana. Stuttgart: Strecker und Schröder.
Movses Khorenatsi. Hayoc‘ patmut‘yun (History of Armenians) (Orig. text Abeghyan M., Harutiunyan S., Arm. transl. St. Malkhasyants). Yerevan: Yerevan State University Press, 1981 (in Armenian).
Movses Khorenatsi. Istorija Armenii (History of Armenia) (Rus. transl., preface and comments G. Sarkisyan). Yerevan: Hayastan, 1990 (in Russian).
Nefedyev, N. 1839. Vzgljad na Armjanskuju oblast. Iz putevix zapisok N. Nefedyeva (View of Armenian Region. Travel Notes of N. Nefedyev). St Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo Grech (in Russian).
Orbeli, I.A., Struve, V.V. (eds) 1960. Issledovanija po istorii i kul’ture narodov Vostoka (Investigations on History and Culture of People of the East). Moscow – Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR (in Russian).
Özfirat, A. 2014a. Aktaş: An Urartian fortress on the northern slope of Mt. Ağrı-Araxes Valley, in: Özfirat 2014b: 111-120.
Özfirat, A. (ed.) 2014b. Scripta. Essays in Honour of Veli Sevin. A Life Immersed in Archaeology. İstanbul: Ege Yayınları.
Özfirat, A. 2017a. Eriqua and Minuahinili: An Early Iron Age-Nairi kingdom and Urartian province on the northern slope of Mt. Ağrı (Settlement complexes at Melekli and Karakoyunlu). TÜBA-AR 21: 63-92.
Özfirat, A. 2017b. The Late Bronze – Early Iron Age – Urartu complex at Bozkurt on the southern slope of Mt. Ağrı, in: Rova, Tonussi 2017: 299-310.
Özfırat, A. 2017c. Melekli-Kültepe (Iğdır) Mound, Urartian fortress and columbarium in Minuahinili (Karakoyunlu) on the northern slope of Mt Ağrı. OLBA 25: 161-182.
Özfırat, A. 2018. The Urartian fortress at Ömerağa-Gölyüzü on the southern slope of Mt. Ağrı (Bozkurt Settlement Complex), in the city of Minuahinili (Karakoyunlu). CollAn 17: 191-209.
Papazyan, V.H. 1990. Hayastani aṛevtrakan ułinerə miǰazgayin aṛevtri volortum XVI-XVII dd. (Trade Roads of Armenia in the Sphere of International Trade in the 16th-17th Centuries). Yerevan: Haykakan SSH GA hratarakč‘ut‘yun (in Armenian).
Pavstos Buzand. Patmut‘yun Hayoc‘ (History of Armenia) (Arm. transl., preface and comments St. Malkhasyants). Yerevan: Hayastan, 1968 (in Armenian).
Pavstos Buzand. Istorija Armenii (History of Armenia) (Rus. transl. M.A. Gevorkyan). Yerevan: Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk Armjanskoj SSR, 1953 (in Russian).
Ploytapxoy Bioi Пapallhloi. T. I (Rus. transl. S.P. Markish, C.I. Sobolevskii), 1961; T. II (M.E. Grabar-Passek, S.P. Markish), 1963; T. III (S.P. Markish), 1964. Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).
Richthofen, F. 1877-1883. Ergebnisse eigener Reisen und darauf gegrundeter Studien. Bd. 1-4. Berlin: Verlag von Dietrich Reimer.
Ristvet, L., Gopnik, H., Bakshaliyev, V., Lau, H., Ashurov, S., Bryant, R. 2012a. On the edge of Empire: 2008 and 2009 excavations at Oğlanqala, Azerbaijan. AJA 116/2: 321-362.
Ristvet, L., Gopnik, H., Bakshaliyev, V., Ashurov, S. 2012b. 2010-2011 American-Azerbaijani excavations at Oğlanqala, in: Talibov 2012: 39-65.
Rova, E., Tonussi, M. (eds) 2017. At the Northern Frontier of Near Eastern Archaeology (Subartu 38). Turnhout: Brepols.
Sargsyan, G. (ed.) 1969. Hayagitakan hetazotut‘yunner (Armenological Investigations). Yerevan: Haykakan SSH GA hratarakč‘ut‘yun (in Armenian).
Sebeosi Episkoposi Patmut‘yun (Sebeos. History), Orig. text after St. Malkhasyants, 4th publication. Yerevan: Armfan, 1939 (in Armenian).
Sebeos. Istorija (History) (Rus. transl. St. Malkhasyants). Yerevan: Armfan, 1939 (in Russian).
Shahkhatunyants, H. Bishop 2014. Storagrut‘yun Kat‘ołike Ēǰmiacni ev hing gavaṛac‘n Araratay (1842). (Descriprion of St. Echmiadzin and five provinces of Ayrarat. 1842). Vagharshapat: St. Etchmiadzin Cathedral publication (in Armenian).
Solodukho, Yu.S. 1960. K voprosu ob armjano-irakskix torgovyx svjazax v IV v. (On the problem of Armenian-Iraqi trade relations in the 4th century), in: Orbeli, Struve 1960: 128-132.
Strabo. Geography in 17 books (Rus. transl. G.A. Stratanovskii). Leningrad: Nauka, 1964 (in Russian).
Tacitus. Annales. Opera tomi duo. Tomus prior (Rus. transl. A.S. Bobovich, Ya.M. Boriskovskii, M.E. Sergeenko). Leningrad: Nauka, 1969 (in Russian).
Talibov, V. (ed.) 2012. Naxçıvan: Ilk yaşayış ve şǝhǝrsalma yeri kim (20-24 iyul 2011-ci ildekeçirilmiş beynǝlxalq simpoziumun materialları). Naxçıvan: Azǝrbaycan Milli Elmlǝr Akademiyası Naxçıvan bölmesi.
Trever, C.V. 1953. Očerki po istorii kul’tury drevnej Armenii (II v. do n.é. – IV v. n.é.) /(Remarks on the History of Culture of Ancient Armenia (2nd century BC – 4th century AD)/). Moscow – Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR (in Russian).
Trifonov, V.G., Karakhanyan, A.S. 2004. Geodinamika i istorija civilizacij (Geodynamic and History of Civilizations). Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).
Xenophontis Expeditio Cyri / Kypoy Anabasis (Rus. transl. M.I. Maximova). Moscow – Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR, 1951 (in Russian).
Yeremyan, S.T. 1963. Hayastanə əst “Ašxarhac‘oyc‘”-i (Armenia according the “Ashkharhatsuits”). Yerevan: Haykakan SSH GA hratarakč‘ut‘yun (in Armenian).
Zardaryan, M.H. 1982a. Krkin angam Ok‘sus-Kyrus-Phasis ǰrayin čanaparhi masin (One more time on the river route Oxus-Kyrus-Phasis), in: Abrahamyan, Kharatyan 1982: 16-17 (in Armenian).
Zardaryan, M.H. 1982b. Širakə aṛaǰavorasiakan integrac‘ion hamakargum (m.t‘.a. I hazaramyakum) /(Shirak in frames of integration structure of the Near East (I millennium BC/)), in: Harutyunyan 1982: 10-11 (in Armenian).
Zardaryan, M.H. 1999. Velikij Šelkovij put’: istorija, konjuktura, perspektivy (The Great Silk Road: History, conjucture, perspectives). Central’naja Azija i Kavkaz (Central Asia and the Caucasus) 4(5): 175-183 (in Russian).
Zardaryan, M.H. 2009. Kommunikac‘ionnaja os’ “Jug-Sever” v sisteme vnešnix svjazej Armjanskogo nagorja (I tys. do n.é.) /(Communication Axis “South-North” in system of trade relations of the Armenian Highland (I millennium BC)/). AGV 2/3-1: 50-65 (in Russian).
Zardaryan, M.H. 2018. The Early Iron Age settlement of Artashat and problems of chrono-topography of the site (pre-Classical period). AJNES 12/2: 105-145.
Zardaryan, M., Yengibaryan, N., Sargsyan, H. 2017(2018). Syunik‘-Arc‘axi aṛevtrayin ułinerə vorpes Hayastani ev Merjavor Arevelk‘i čanaparhagitut‘yan hetazotman modul (The trade network of Syunik-Artsakh as a modulus for explorations in Roadology of the Near East), in: Hakobyan et al. 2017(2018): 55-65 (in Armenian).
Zardaryan, M.H., Yengibaryan, N.G., Sargsyan, H.G. 2018. Problemy izučeniya istoričeskix kommunikacionnyx sistem (ot napravlenija k doroge) /(Problems of exploration of ancient communication systems (from direction to the road)/), in: Berdnikov, Lipnina 2018: 358-362 (in Russian).
Zardaryan, M.H., Yengibaryan, N.G., Sargsyan, H.G. 2022. Gełark‘unik‘i patmakan ułinerə Haykakan leṛnašxarhi hałordakc‘man hamakargum (Ancient roads of Gegharkunik province in the communication system of the Armenian Highlands), in: Badalyan et al. 2022: 61-70 (in Armenian).
Zimansky, P.E. 1985. Ecology and Empire: The Structure of the Urartian State (Studies in Ancient Oriental Civilization 41). Chicago. Illinois: The Oriental Institute.