Embedding spatial analyses in culture-historical discourse. Experiences from Jordan and Cyprus
Abstract
Before discussing specific case studies, some general remarks on the application of computer-based, spatial analytical methods within landscape archaeological research seem appropriate. Particularly, the underlying understanding of the term ‘landscape archaeology’ must be clarified, which is often only very vaguely defined. As landscape archaeology has grown increasingly en vogue in recent years, a universally valid definition remains elusive. Serving ‘[…] as an envelope for anything […]’, landscape archaeology continues to act as ‘[…] a reasonable umbrella term for all research in the social construction of space’. However, one consensus seems to understand it not merely as an environmental archaeology which is only concerned with the physical landscape, but – importantly – also as an approach that studies the meaningfulness of landscapes for past human societies, and the interactive role of landscapes and human activities through time. Considering landscapes both as a ‘product of natural features’ as well as ‘the result of human actions’, it becomes clear that past peoples lie at the centre of landscape archaeology. Although distinctly interdisciplinary, its core is therefore deeply rooted in the humanities, aiming at researching past human-environmental relations on the basis of material culture within its natural environmental context. Landscape archaeological studies research the genesis of cultural landscapes (Kulturlandschaftsgenese), i.e. all forms of natural landscape changes that were caused or influenced (by) humans, from a distinctly archaeological, material-based perspective. In addition to traditional archaeological research of material remains (i.e. archaeological surveys, excavations, detailed material studies), landscape archaeological studies employ different methods from (a) other disciplines of the humanities (e.g. ancient history, epigraphy or numismatics), (b) the natural and geosciences (e.g. geography, biology or ecology), as well as (c) computer sciences, including remote sensing methodologies, spatial statistics and other computer-based spatial analyses.
References
Cadogan, G. 2004. Hector Catling and the genesis of the Cyprus Survey, in M. Iacovou (ed.) Archaeological field survey in Cyprus. Past history, future potentials. Proceedings of a conference held by the Archaeological Research Unit of the University of Cyprus, 1-2 December 2000 (British School at Athens Studies 11): 17–22. London: The British School at Athens. Catling, H.W. 1982. The ancient topography of the Yalias valley. Report of the Department of Antiquities Cyprus 1982: 227–236. Crema, E.R., A. Bevan and M.W. Lake 2010. A probabilistic framework for assessing spatio-temporal point patterns in the archaeological record. Journal of Archaeological Science 37: 1118–1130. David, B. and J. Thomas 2008. Landscape archaeology: Introduction, in B. David and J. Thomas (eds) Handbook of landscape archaeology: 27–43. Walnut Creek: Leftcoast Press. Donnellan, L. 2016. ‘Greek colonisation’ and Mediterranean networks patterns of mobility and interaction at Pithekoussai. Journal of Greek Archaeology 1: 109–148. Donnellan, L. 2020. Archaeological networks and social interaction, in L. Donnellan (ed.) Archaeological networks and social interaction: 1–19. London: Routledge. Fachard, S. 2012. La défense du territoire. Étude de la chôra et de ses fortifications (Eretria. Fouilles et Recherches XXI). Gollion: Infolio éditions. Fachard, S. 2016. Modelling the territories of Attic demes: A computational approach, in J. Bintliff and K. Rutter (eds) The archaeology of Greece and Rome. Studies in honour of Anthony Snodgrass: 192–222. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. Fachard, S. and A.R. Knodell 2020. Out of Attica: Modeling mobility in the Mycenaean period, in N. Papadimitriou, J.C. Wright, S. Fachard, N. Polychronakou-Sgouritsa and E. Andrikou (eds) Αthens and Attica in Prehistory. Proceedings of the International Conference Athens, 27-31 May 2015: 407–416. Oxford: Archaeopress Publishing Ltd. Farinetti, E. 2011. Boeotian landscapes. A GIS-based study for the reconstruction and interpretation of the archaeological datasets of Boeotia (British Archaeological Reports International Series 2195). Oxford: Archaeopress. Farinetti, E., S. Herman and F. Niccolucci 2010. Fuzzy logic application to artifact surface survey data, in F. Niccolucci and S. Hermon (eds) Beyond the artifact digital interpretation of the past, Proceedings of CAA2004 Prato 13–17 April 2004: 125–129. Budapest: Archaeolingua. Fiema, Z.T. 2015. Petra, in G. Schöllgen, H. Brakmann, S. de Blaauw, T. Fuhrer, H. Leppin, W. Löhr, H.-G. Nesselrath and I. Tanaseanu (eds) Reallexikon für antike und christentum. Sachwörterbuch zur auseinandersetzung des Christentums mit der Antiken Welt XXVII: 349–387. Stuttgart: Anton Hiersemann. Fourrier, S. 2002. Les territoires des royaumes chypriotes archaïques: une esquisse de géographie historique. Cahiers du Centre d`Études Chypriotes 32: 135–146. Fourrier, S. 2007. La coroplastie chypriote archaïque. Lyon: Maison de l’Orient et de la Méditerranée. Fourrier, S. 2014. Rois et cités de Chypre: questions de territoires. Cahiers du Centre d’Etudes Chypriotes 44: 119–36. Georgiou, G. 2024. Resources, technological innovations and networks in central Cyprus during the cypro-archaic period, in S.G. Schmid and W.M. Kennedy (eds) The topography of ancient Idalion and its territory: 259–282 (Studia Cyprologica Berolinensia 2). Berlin: Logos Verlag. Gillings, M., P. Hacigüzeller and G.R. Lock (eds) 2020. Archaeological spatial analysis. A methodological guide. New York: Routledge. Gordon, J.M. 2023. The ‘fuzzy’ world of Cyriot Long Late Antiquity. Continuity and disruption betwixt the global and local, in P. Panayides and I. Jacobs (eds) Cyprus in the long Late Antiquity. History and archaeology between the sixth and eighth centuries: 243–263. Philadelphia: Oxbow Books. Haas, T.C. 2012. Beyond dots on the map: intensive survey data and the interpretation of small sites and off-sites distributions, in P.A.J. Attema and G. Schörner (eds) Comparative issues in the archaeology of the Roman rural landscape: site classification between survey, excavation and historical categories (Journal of Roman Archaeology Supplementary Series 88): 55–79. Portsmouth, Rhode Island. Hadjisavvas, S. 2004. Surveying after Catling: the work of the Department of Antiquities Survey Branch since 1960, in M. Iacovou (ed.) Archaeological field survey in Cyprus. Past history, future potentials. Proceedings of a conference held by the Archaeological Research Unit of the University of Cyprus, 1-2 December 2000 (British School at Athens Studies 11): 37–41. London: The British School at Athens. Hamer, W.B. and D. Knitter 2018. Fuzzy Landscapes—Fuzzy analyses with a focus on raster data. (version 1.0). Zenodo. https://zenodo.org/record/1747005. Hamer, W.B., D. Knitter, S.B. Grimm, B. Serbe, B.V. Eriksen, O. Nakoinz and R. Duttmann 2019. Location modelling of final palaeolithic sites in northern Germany. Geosciences 9.430: 1–14. https://doi.org/10.3390/geosciences9100430. Haupt, P. 2012. Landschaftsarchäologie. Eine einführung. Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft. Hermary, A. 2013. Recherches récentes sur le territoire et les frontières des royaumes chypriotes (VIIIe-IVe siècles av. J.-C.), in M.A. Guggisberg (ed.) Grenzen in ritual und kult der antike: Internationales Kolloquium, Basel, 5.-6. November 2009 (Schweizerische Beiträge zur Altertumswissenschaft 40): 115–1 29. Basel: Schwabe Verlag. Hoer, A. 2024. Die Höhenbefestigungen Samniums vom 4.-1. Jh. v. Chr. Eine landschafts- und siedlungsarchäologische Analyse (Züricher Archäologische Forschungen 12). Basel: LIBRUM Publishers & Editors LLC. Iacovou, M. 2002. From ten to naught. Formation, consolidation and abolition of Cyprus’ Iron age polities. Cahiers du Centre d`Études Chypriotes 32: 73–87. Iacovou, M. 2012. From regional gateway to Cypriot kingdom. Copper deposits and copper routes in the chora of Paphos, in V. Kassianidou and G. Papasavvas (eds) Eastern Mediterranean metallurgy and metalwork in the second millennium BC. A conference in honour of James D. Muhly Nicosia, 10th-11th October 2009: 58–69. Oxford: Oxbow Books. Iacovou, M. 2013a. Historically elusive and internally fragile island polities: The intricacies of Cyprus’s political geography in the iron age. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 370: 15–47. Iacovou, M. 2013b. Paphos before Palaepaphos. New evidence for the history of the Paphian kingdom, in D. Michaelidies (ed.) Epigraphy, numismatics, prosopography and history of ancient Cyprus papers in honour of Ino Nicolaou (Studies in Mediterranean archaeology and literature. Pocket Book 179): 275–291. Uppsala: Åströms Förlag. Iacovou, M. 2014. Political economies and landscape transformations. The case of ancient Paphos, in J.M. Webb (ed.) Structure, measurement and meaning: Insights into the prehistory of Cyprus. Studies on prehistoric Cyprus in honour of David Frankel (Studies in Mediterranean Archaeology 143): 161–174. Uppsala: Åströms Förlag. Iacovou, M. 2018. From the Late Cypriot polities to the Iron Age ‘kingdoms’. Understanding the political landscape of Cyprus from within, in A. Cannavò and L. Thély (eds) Les royaumes de Chypre à l’épreuve de l’histoire: transitions et ruptures de la fin de l’âge du Bronze au début de l’époque hellénistique (Bulletin de Correspondance Hellénique Supplément 60): 7–28. Athens: Ecole française d’Athènes. Iacovou, M. 2019. Palaepaphos: Unlocking the landscape context of the sanctuary of the Cypriot Goddess. Open Archaeology 5: 204–234. Iacovou, M. 2021. The political structure of pre-Ptolemaic Cyprus. Cycles of devolution and territorialization, in M.-J. Werlings, A. Guieu and J. Zurbach (eds) Le pouvoir et la parole. Mélanges en mémoire de Pierre Carlier: 225–256. Nancy: Editions de Boccard. Kassianidou, V. 2013. The exploitation of the landscape: Metal resources and the copper trade during the age of the Cypriot City-Kingdoms. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 370: 49–82. Kassianidou, V. 2024. The topography of copper production in the Iron Age city-kingdom of Idalion, in S.G. Schmid and W.M. Kennedy (eds) The topography of ancient Idalion and its territory: 283–304 (Studia Cyprologica Berolinensia 2). Berlin: Logos Verlag. Kearns, C. 2023. The rural landscapes of Archaic Cyprus. An archaeology of environmental and social change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Kennedy, W.M. 2013. The hills have eyes: GIS-based studies on a possible watchtower on Umm al-Biyara, in M. Mouton and S.G. Schmid (eds) Men on the rocks. The formation of Nabataean Petra. Proceedings of a conference held in Berlin 2-4 December 2011: 271–293. Berlin: Logos Verlag. Kennedy, W.M. 2016a. Reassessing the impact of natural landscape factors on spatial strategies in the Petra hinterland in Nabataean-Roman times. Proceedings of the seminar for Arabian Studies 46: 137–164. Kennedy, W.M. 2016b. Ein versuch einer Higuchi-Viewshed-analyse am beispiel eines wachturms auf der Umm al-Biyara in Petra, Jordanien, in U. Lieberwirth and I. Herzog (eds) 3D-Anwendungen in der Archäologie. Computeranwendungen und Quantitative Methoden in der Archäologie – Workshop der AG CAA und des Exzellenzclusters Topoi 2013 (Berlin Studies of the Ancient World 34): 157–179. Berlin: Edition Topoi. Kennedy, W.M. 2019. A cultural landscape characterization of the Petraean hinterland in Nabataean-Roman times: An overview, in A. Lichtenberger, O. Tal and Z. Weiss (eds) Judaea/Palaestina and Arabia: Cities and hinterlands in Roman and Byzantine times (Archaeology and economy in the ancient world. Session 8: The role of the city in the ancient economy: Urban infrastructure, relations between town and country 44): 125–140. Heidelberg: Propylaeum. Kennedy, W.M. 2020a. The Nabataeans as travellers between the desert and the sown, in P.M.M.G. Akkermans (ed.) Landscapes of survival. The archaeology and epigraphy of Jordan’s North-Eastern desert and beyond: 235–254. Leiden: Sidestone Press. Kennedy, W.M. 2020b. Investigating the socio-political make-up of rural Petra. The Petra Hinterland Social Landscapes Project, in N. al-Rawabdeh and R. Hunziker-Rodewald (eds) Third International Conference on Petra and Nabataean Culture (Jordan Journal for History and Archaeology 14. 4. (Special Issue)): 249–271. Amman: The University of Jordan. Kennedy, W.M. 2021. Terra Petraea. The archaeological landscape of the Petraean hinterland from the Hellenistic to the Byzantine period. Berlin: Logos Verlag. Kennedy, W.M. 2023. The Petra Hinterland Social Landscapes Project (PHSLP). Summary report on the first season, 2022. Palestine Exploration Quarterly 155: 267–273. Kennedy, W.M. 2024. How many micro-regions in rural Petra? Current approaches to researching social landscapes in the hinterland of Petra, Jordan, in F. Pirson, B. Schütt and Th. Schulz (eds) Micro-regions as spaces of socio-ecological Interaction. 1st Milestone Workshop of the Project ‘The Transformation of the Pergamon Micro-Region between the Hellenistic and the Roman Imperial Period’ Istanbul, 11–12 March 2022 (Tagungen und Kongresse 3): 113–132. Wiesbaden: Reichert Verlag. Kennedy, W.M. and D. Knitter. 2024. Defining the rural environs of ancient Idalion: A fuzzy landscape archaeological approach for determining Idalion’s resource potential, in S.G. Schmid and W.M. Kennedy (eds) The topography of ancient Idalion and its territory (Studia Cyprologica Berolinensia 2): 305–330. Berlin: Logos Verlag. Knapp, A.B. 2023. Late Bronze Age Cyprus: A reassessment of settlement structure and society. Nicosia: Astrom. Knapp, A.B. and N. Meyer. 2020. Cyprus: Bronze Age demise, Iron Age regeneration, in G.D. Middleton (ed.) Collapse and transformation: the late Bronze Age to early Iron Age in the Aegean: 237–246. Oxford: Oxbow Books. Knappett, C. 2011. An archaeology of interaction. Network perspectives on material culture and society. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Knappett, C. 2020. Relational concepts and challenges to network analysis in social archaeology, in L. Donnellan (ed.) Archaeological networks and social interaction: 20–37. London: Routledge. Knitter D., W. Bebermeier, J. Krause and B. Schütt. 2018. Critical physical geography in practice: Landscape Archaeology, in R. Lave, C. Biermann and S.N. Lane (eds) The Palgrave handbook of critical physical geography: 179–200. Cham: Palgrave Macmillian. Knodell, A.R. 2021. Societies in transition in early Greece An archaeological history. Oakland: University of California Press. Knodell, A.R., S.E. Alcock, C.A. Tuttle, C.F. Cloke, T. Erickson-Gini, C. Feldman, G. Rollefson, M. Sinibaldi, T.M. Urban, C. Vella. 2017. The Brown University Petra Archaeological Project. Landscape Archaeology in the Northern Hinterland of Petra, Jordan. American Journal of Archaeology 121.4: 621–683. Knitter, D., G. Günther, W.B. Hamer, T. Keßler, J. Seguin, I. Unkel, E. Weiberg, R. Duttmann and O. Nakoinz. 2019. Land use patterns and climate change – a modeled scenario of the Late Bronze Age in Southern Greece. Environmental Research Letters 14, 125003: 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ab5126. Körner, C. 2017. Die Zyprischen königtümer im schatten der grossreiche des vorderen Orients: Studien zu den zyprischen monarchien vom 8. bis zum 4. Jh. v. Chr. Leuven: Peeters. Kouki, P. 2012. The hinterland of a city. Rural settlement and land use in the Petra region from the Nabataean-Roman to the Early Islamic Period. Helsinki: Helsinki University Print. Kouki, P. and M. Lavento (eds) 2013. Petra - The mountain of Aaron. The Finnish Archaeological Project in Jordan. Volume III. The Archaeological Survey. Helsinki: Societas Scientiarum Fennica. Lindner, M. 1992. Abu Khusheiba - a newly discovered Nabataean settlement and caravan station between Wadi ‘Arabah and Petra. Studies in the History and Archaeology of Jordan 4: 263–267. Lindner, M. 2003. Über Petra hinaus. Archäologische erkundungen im südlichen Jordanien. Rahden: Verlag Marie Leidorf GmbH. Lindner, M. and E. Gunsam. 1995. A newly described Nabataean temple near Petra. The Pond temple. Studies in the History and Archaeology of Jordan 5: 199–214. Matzourani, E., K. Kopanias and I. Voskos. 2019. A Great King of Alašiya? The archaeological and textual evidence, in J.M. Kelder and W.J.I. Waal (eds) From ‘Lugal. Gal’ to ‘Wanax’: kingship and political organisation in the Late Bronze Age Aegean: 95–130. Leiden: Sidestone Press. Meier, T. 2012. ‘Landscape‘, ‘environment‘ and a vision of interdisciplinarity, in S.J. Kluiving and E.B. Guttmann-Bond (eds) Landscape archaeology between art and science. From a multi- to an interdisciplinary approach: 503–14. Amsterdam: University Press. Meyer N. and A.B. Knapp. 2021. Resilient social actors in the transition from the Late Bronze to the Early Iron Age on Cyprus. Journal of World Prehistory 34: 433–487. Mills, B.J., M.A. Peeples, W.R. Haas Jr., L. Borck, J.J. Clark and J.M. Roberts Jr. 2015. Multiscalar perspectives on social networks in the Late Prehispanic Southwest. American Antiquity 80.1: 3–24. Mouton, M. and S.G. Schmid (eds) 2013. Men on the rocks. The formation of Nabataean Petra. Proceedings of a conference held in Berlin 2-4 December 2011. Berlin: Logos Verlag. Nakoinz, O. 2012. Datierungskodierung und chronologische Inferenz – Techniken zum Umgang mit unscharfen chronologischen Informationen. Praehistorische Zeitschrift 87.1: 189–207. Nehmé, L. 2013. The installation of social groups in Petra, in M. Mouton and S.G. Schmid (eds) Men on the rocks. The formation of Nabataean Petra. Proceedings of a conference held in Berlin 2-4 December 2011: 113–127. Berlin: Logos Verlag. Papantoniou, G. 2019. Unlocking sacred landscapes: the applicability of a GIS approach to the territorial formation of the Cypro-Archaic and Cypro-Classical polities, in G. Papantoniou, C.E. Morris and A.K. Vionis (eds) Unlocking sacred landscapes: spatial analysis of ritual and cult in the Mediterranean (Studies in Mediterranean Archaeology CLI): 3–26. Nicosia: Astrom Editions. Papantoniou, G. and G. Bourogiannis. 2018. The Cypriot extra-urban sanctuary as a central place: the case of Agia Irini. Land 7, 139: 1–27. https://doi.org/10.3390/land7040139. Papantoniou, G. and N. Kyriakou. 2018. Sacred landscapes and the territoriality of Iron Age Cypriot polities: The applicability of GIS. American Journal of Archaeology 122.4: 541–77. Papantoniou, G. and A. Vionis 2017. Landscape archaeology and sacred space in the eastern Mediterranean: A glimpse from Cyprus. Land 6: 1–18. https://doi.org/10.3390/land6020040. Papantoniou, G. and A. Vionis 2018. The river as an economic asset: Settlement and society in the Xeros Valley in Cyprus. Land 7, 157: 1–29. https://doi.org/10.3390/land7040157. Petit, T. 2019. La naissance des cités-royaumes cypriotes. Oxford: Archaeopress. Popa, C.N. and D. Knitter. 2015. From environment to landscape. Reconstructing environment perception using numerical data. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 23.4: 1285–1306. Rupp, D.W. 1985. Prolegomena to a study of stratification and social organization in Iron Age Cyprus, in M. Thompson, M.T. Garcia and F. Kense (eds) Status, structure, and stratification: Current archaeological reconstructions: Proceedings of the Sixteenth Annual Conference: 119–131. Calgary: University of Calgary, Archaeological Association. Rupp, D.W. 1987. Vive le Roi. The emergence of the state in Iron Age Cyprus, in D.W. Rupp (ed.) Western Cyprus connections. An archaeological symposium held at Brock University, St. Catharines, Ontario, Canada, March 21-22, 1986 (Studies in Mediterranean archaeology 77): 147–161. Göteborg: Paul Åströms Förlag. Rupp, D.W. 1989. Puttin’ on the ritz: Manifestations of high status in Iron Age Cyprus, in E.J. Peltenburg (ed.) Early Society in Cyprus: 336–362. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. Rupp, D.W. 2001. ‘In fertility Cyprus is not inferior to any one of the islands’: A prolegomenon to constructing the economy of Iron Age Cyprus, in D.W. Tandy (ed.) Prehistory and history. Ethnicity, class and political economy: 113–144. Montreal: Black Rose Books. Satraki, A. 2018. Ptolin Edalion: Transitions and breaks in the life of an island Cypriot city-state, in A. Cannavò and L. Thély (eds) Les royaumes de Chypre à l’épreuve de l’histoire: transitions et ruptures de la fin de l’âge du Bronze au début de l’époque hellénistique (Bulletin de Correspondance Hellénique Supplément 60): 147–165. Schmid, S.G. 2013. Foucault and the Nabataeans or what space has to do with it, in M. Mouton and S.G. Schmid (eds) Men on the rocks. The formation of Nabataean Petra. Proceedings of a conference held in Berlin 2-4 December 2011: 251–70. Berlin: Logos Verlag. Schmid, S.G. 2021. Was there a Nabataean identity – And if yes, how many?, in M. Blömer, S. Riedel, M.J. Versluys and E. Winter (eds) Common dwelling place of all the gods. Commagene in its local, regional and global Hellenistic context (Oriens et Occidens 34): 439–474. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag. Schmid, S.G. and W.M. Kennedy (eds) 2024. The topography of ancient Idalion and its territory (Studia Cyprologica Berolinensia 2). Berlin: Logos Verlag. Schmid, S.G. and E. van der Meijden (eds) 2012. Petra - Wunder in der wüste. Begleitbuch zur ausstellung ‘Petra. Wunder in der Wüste. Auf den Spuren von J.L. Burckhardt alias Scheich Ibrahim‘ im Antikenmuseum Basel. Basel: Schwabe. Ulbrich, A. 2008. Kypris. Heiligtümer und kulte weiblicher Gottheiten auf Zypern in der kyproarchaischen und kyproklassischen epoche (Königszeit) (Alter Orient Und Altes Testament 44). Münster: Ugarit-Verlag. Verhagen, P. 2023. Spatial information in archaeology, in A.M. Pollard, R.A. Armitage and C.A. Makarewicz (eds) Handbook of archaeological sciences: 1163–1181. Hoboken: Wiley. Verhagen, P. and A. Sarris. 2023. GIS-based spatial analysis and modelling, in P. Trapero Fernández and A. Carneiro (eds) GIS applications in roman landscape and territory. Methodologies and models in Hispania: 173–182 (British Archaeological Reports International Series 3139). Oxford: BAR Publishing.
Zadeh, L.A. 1965. Fuzzy sets. Information and control 8: 338–353.