The Dating and the Sequence of the Persid Frataraka Revisited
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32028/k.v1i.1164Abstract
Archaeologists and in particular their nit-picking subspecies, the specialists of epigraphy or of numismatics, can be notorious fun-spoilers. Many scholars of ancient history have – at one point or another – undergone the rather frustrating experience that their inventive and frequently clever theories based mainly on their subjective interpretation of the textual evidence provided by the literary tradition are not compatible with the findings of epigraphic or numismatic research. Auxiliary constructions invented to circumnavigate this apparent dilemma tend to make the intended point even weaker the more elaborate they get. The few testimonies of the literary tradition have come upon us in a variously fractured and altered form: In most cases the principal information is transmitted here by late antiquity if not even medieval copies or excerpts of an original source lost a long time ago. They therefore leave open a rather wide space for all kinds of rational reconstructions and erudite opining about their original contents and meaning. In contrast to this type of evidence, epigraphic and numismatic remains have the characteristic quality of bearing direct and not subsequently edited, witness to circumstances and events at the time and place of their origin. Admittedly also coins and inscriptions leave space for various interpretations, but this is much more limited and the evidence provided by this type of source can hardly be contradicted in a forthright way.
References
Ahrabi, M., H. Löschner, and W. Müseler. “A new tetradrachm of the frataraka from Persepolis?” Journal of the Oriental Numismatic Society, 231 (2018): 7-9.
Allotte de la Fuye, F.M. “Numismatique de la Perside.” Corolla Numismatica. Numismatic Essays in Honor of Barclay V. Head. Edited by G. Hill. London, 1906.
Alram, M. “Nomina Propria Iranica in Nummis – Materialgrundlagen zu den iranischen Personennamen auf antiken Münzen. Iranisches Personennamenbuch IV, ed. Mayrhofer, M. and Schmitt, R. Wien, 1986.
Alram, M. “Die Vorbildwirkung der Arsakidischen Münzprägung.” Litterae Numismaticae Vindobonenses III., Wien, 1987. 117-146.
Alram, M. “Eine neue Drachme des Vahbarz (Oborzos) aus der Persis?. ” Litterae Numismaticae Vindobonenses III. Wien, 1987. 147-155.
BarKochva, B. The Seleucid Army – Organisation and Tactics in the great campaigns. Cambridge, 1976.
Bickerman, E. “The Seleucids and the Achaemenids.” Rendic. Lincei 76 (1966): 87-117.
Calmeyer, P. “Vom Reisehut zur Kaiserkrone – Stand der archäologischen Forschung zu den iranischen Kronen. ” AMI NF10 (1977):168-190.
Choksy, J.K. “Gesture in Ancient Iran and Central Asia II : Proskynesis and the bent Forefinger.” Bulletin of the Asia Institute NS 4 (1990): 201-207.
Chrubasik, B. Kings and Usurpers in the Seleucid Empire: The Men who would be King. Oxford, 2016.
Curtis, V.S. “The Frataraka coins of Persis : Bridging the gap between Achaemenid and Sasanian Persia.” World of Achaemenid Persia, ed. Curtis, J. and Simpson, St. J., London 2010. 379-394.
Engels, D. “A new Frataraka-chronology. ” Latomus 72 (2013): 28-82.
v. Gall, H. “Die Kopfbedeckung der persischen Ornats bei den Achaemeniden.” AMI NF 7 (1974): 145-161.
v. Gall, H. “Die Kopfbedeckungen des medischen Ornats in achaemenidischer und hellenstischer Zeit.” Akten des XIII. Internationalen Kongresses für Archaeologie in Berlin 1988, ed. Deutsches Archaeologisches Institut Berlin.1990. 320-323.
Grabowski, M. “Abdissares of Adiabene and the Batas-Herir Relief.” Swiatowit. Annual of the Institute of Archaeology of the University of Warsaw 9, 50 (2011): 117-139.
Haerink, E. and Overlaet, B. “Altar Shrine and Firealtars? – Architectural Representations on Frataraka Coinage.” Iranica Antiqua Vol. XLIII (2008): 207-223.
Hannestad, L. and Potts, D.T. “Tempel architecture in the Seleucid kingdom.” Religion and religious practice in the Seleucid kingdom, ed. Bilde, P. et al. (Aarhus: Aarhus: Aarhus University Press, 1990), 91-124.
Herzfeld, E. Archaeological History of Iran. London. 1935.
Herzfeld, E. Iran in the Ancient East. Chicago, 1941.
Hill, G.F. A Catalogue of Greek coins in the British Museum: Catalogue of the coins of Arabia, Mesopotamia and Persia. London: Oxford University Press, 1922.
Hoover, O.D. “Overstruck Seleucid coins.” Seleucid coins – A comprehensive catalogue. Vol. 1. ed A. Houghton and C. Lorber. (New York: ANS, 2008), 209-217.
Houghton, A., and C. Lorber. Seleucid coins – A comprehensive catalogue, Part I. New York: ANS, 2002.
Houghton, A., C. Lorber, and O. Hoover. Seleucid coins – A comprehensive catalogue, Part II. New York: ANS, 2008.
Ito, G. “Gathica XIV-XV Syenian Frataraka and Persid Fratarak / New Iranian elements in Ancient Aramaic.” Orient 12 (1976): 47-66.
Jenkins, G.K. “Coin Hoards from Pasargadae.” Iran 3 (1965): 41-52.
Jenkins, G.K. “Coins.” Pasargadae. A report on the excavations conducted by the British Institute of Persian Studies from 1961 to 1963, ed. D. Stronach. (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1978), 185-198.
Klinkott, H. Der Satrap. Ein achaemenidischer Amtsträger und seine Handlungsspielräume. Berlin: Verlag Antike, 2005.
Klose, D., and W. Müseler. Statthalter, Rebellen, Könige. Die Münzen von Persepolis von Alexander dem Großen bis zu den Sasaniden. München: Staatliche Münzsammlung, 2008.
Kovacs, F.L. “Two Pharaonic Portraits.” JNG 50 (2000): 55-60.
Kovacs, F.L. Armenian Coinage in the Classical Period. Lancaster, PA: CNG, 2016.
Kritt, B. The early Seleucid mint of Susa. Lancaster, PA: CNG, 1997.
Kritt, B. The Seleucid mint of Ai Khanoum. Lancaster PA 2016
De Morgan, J. Manuel de numismatique orientale de l’ antiquité et du moyen âge. Paris: Geuthner, 1923.
Müseler, W. “Die sogenannten dunklen Jahrhunderte der Persis – Anmerkungen zu einem lange vernachlässigten Thema. ” JNG 55/56 (2005/2006): 75-103.
Müseler, W., and Kh. Rhezakhani. “Persis – History and Coinage.” Numismatic Art of Persia – The Sunrise Collection, ed. B. Nelson. Lancaster, (PA: CNG, 2011), 262-290.
Newell, E.T. The coinage of the Eastern Seleucid mints from Seleucus I to Antiochus III. New York: American Numismatic Society, 1938.
Plischke, S. Die Seleukiden und Iran : Die seleukidische Herrschaftspolitik in den östlichen Satrapien. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 2014.
Rhezakhani, Kh. “Arsacid, Elymaean and Persid coinage.” The Oxford handbook of Ancient Iran. ed. D.T. Potts, (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013), 766-777.
Schmidt, E.F. Persepolis I : Structures, Reliefs, Inscriptions. Chicago, 1953.
Sellwood, D. The coinage of Parthia. London, 1980.
Sellwood, D “Minor states in Southern Iran.” The Cambridge History of Ancient Iran3,1-2 – The Seleucid, Parthian and Sasanian periods, ed. E. Yarshater, (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983), 299-321.
Shayegan, M.R. Arsacids and Sasanians. Political ideology in post-Hellenistic and late antique Persia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011.
Shayegan, M.R. “The Arsacids and Commagene.” The Parthian and Early Sasanian Empires – Adapatation and Expansion. Proceedings of a Conference held in Vienna 14-16 June 2012, ed. V.S. Curtis, E.J. Pendleton, M. Alram and T. Daryaee, (Oxford: Oxbow, 2016), 8-22.
Stronach, D. Pasargadae. A report on the excavations conducted by the British Institute of Persian Studies from 1961 to 1963. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1978.
Strootman, R. “Imperial Persianism : Seleucids, Arsacids and Frataraka.” Persianism in Antiquity. ed. J. Strootman, and M.J. Versluys, (Stuttgart: Franz Steiner 2017), 177-200.
Summerer, L. “Achaemeniden am Schwarzen Meer – Bemerkungen zum spätarchaischen Marmorkopf aus Herakleia Pontike.” ANES 42 (2005): 231-252.
van t’Haaff, P.A., and D.S. Van Horn. A catalogue of the coins of the kingdom of Persis 280 BC – AD 224. Lancaster, PA: CNG, forthcoming.
Walser, G. Die Völkerschaften auf den Reliefs von Persepolis. Berlin, 1966.
Wiesehöfer, J. “Die sogenannten, dunklen Jahrhunderte“ der Persis. ” Zetemata 90. München: C.H. Beck, 1994.
Wiesehöfer, J. “Frataraka rule in Early Seleucid Persis : A new appraisal.” Creating a Hellenistic world, ed. A. Erskine and L. Llewellyn-Jones, (Swansea: Classical Press of Wales, 2010), 107-121.
Wiesehöfer, J. “Frataraka and Seleucids.” The Oxford handbook of Ancient Iran, ed. D.T. Potts. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013), 718-727
