Thirty years in the making: A critical overview of the Kura-Araxes periodization from a radiocarbon perspective
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32028/ajnes.v16i1-2.1836Keywords:
Kura-Araxes, radiocarbon, periodization, calibration, Bayesian chronological modelingAbstract
The chronology of the Kura-Araxes culture has long been a matter of debate, particularly as regards its internal periodization. To date, two main periodization systems have been proposed, which argue, respectively, for a three-part and two-part scheme. Despite the acquisition of new 14C and archaeological datasets, universal consent on this issue still hasn’t been reached. This paper reviews the state of the art in chronological studies on the Kura-Araxes culture and provides a critical assessment of the two periodization systems since the introduction of radiocarbon dating in the South Caucasus. The discussion demonstrates that the understanding of the Kura-Araxes chronology exceeds mere questions of ‘objective’ chronometric agreement, as seen in the way that different archaeological agendas have influenced the interpretation of ambiguous calibrated data, and vice versa. Finally, the paper highlights the potential of Bayesian chronological modeling to disambiguate chronometric evidence and exploit archaeological knowledge to the benefit of regionalized periodization frameworks.
References
Akhundov, T. 2004. South Caucasus in the Neolithic to Early Bronze Age: The question of epochs and periods, in: Sagona 2004: 421-436.
Areshian, G.E., Ghafadaryan, K.K. 1996. Haykakan leṙnašxarhi čartarapetut‘yunə naxnadaryan-hamaynakan hasarakargi ev petakan aṙaǰin kazmavorumneri žamanakašrǰanum (The architecture of the Armenian Highland during the periods of primitive societies and first state formations), in: Tiratsyan 1996: 14-86 (in Armenian).
Avetisyan, P., Bobokhyan, A. (eds) 2021. Archaeology of Armenia in Regional Context. Proceedings of the International Conference Dedicated to the 60th Anniversary of the Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography, Held on July 9-11, 2019 in Yerevan. Yerevan: Publishing House of the Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography.
Badalyan, R. 2003. Rannebronzovoe poselenie Aparan III (Early Bronze Age settlement of Aparan III), in: Kalantaryan, Badalyan 2003: 20-26 (in Russian).
Badalyan, R. 2014. New data on the periodization and chronology of the Kura-Araxes culture. Paléorient 40/2: 71-92.
Badalyan, R. 2018. The chronology of the Kura-Araxes: New data and old problems of periodization and chronology of the Early Bronze Age materials in Armenia. AJNES 12/1: 51-65.
Badalyan, R. 2021. From homogeneity to heterogeneity. The periodization and chronology of the Kura-Araxes: The view from Armenia, in: Giemsch, Hansen 2021: 211-222.
Badalyan, R., Avetisyan, P. 2007. Bronze and Early Iron Age sites in Armenia (BAR International Series 1697). Oxford: Archaeopress.
Badalyan, R., Avetisyan, P., Smith, A. 2009. Periodization and chronology of Southern Caucasia: From the Early Bronze Age through the Iron III period, in: Smith et al. 2009: 33-93.
Badalyan, R., Edens, C., Kohl, P.L., Tonikyan, V. 1992. Archaeological investigations at Horom in the Shirak Plain of Northwestern Armenia. Iran 30: 31-48.
Badalyan, R.S., Kohl, P., Stronach, D., Tonikyan, A. 1994. Preliminary report on the 1993 excavations at Horom, Armenia. Iran 32: 1-30.
Badalyan, R.S., Smith, A.T., Lindsay, I., Khtchadourian, L., Avetisyan, P. 2008. Village, fortress, and town in Bronze and Iron Age Southern Caucasia: A preliminary report on the 2003- 2006 investigations of Project ArAGATS on the Tsaghkhahovit Plain, Republic of Armenia. AMIT 20: 45-105.
Batiuk, S., Hovespyan, R., Rothman, M., Samei, S. In press. Unraveling the Kura-Araxes cultural tradition across space and time. ANES.
Braidwood, R.J., Braidwood, L.S. 1960. Excavations in the Plain of Antioch I. The Earlier Assemblages, Phases A-J (OIP 61). Chicago, Ill.: The University of Chicago Press.
Bronk Ramsey, C. 2017. Methods for summarizing radiocarbon datasets. Radiocarbon 59/6: 1809-1833.
Burney, Ch.A., Lang, D.M. 1971. The Peoples of the Hills: Ancient Ararat and Caucasus. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
Chataigner, C. 1995. La Transcaucasie au Néolithique et au Chalcolithique (BAR International Series 624). Oxford: Tempus Reparatum.
Chataigner, C., Palumbi, G. (eds) 2014. The Kura-Araxes Culture from the Caucasus to Iran, Anatolia and the Levant: Between Unity and Diversity (Paléorient 40/2). Paris: CNRS Éditions.
Di Nocera, G.M. 2000. Radiocarbon datings from Arslantepe and Norşuntepe: The fourth-third millennium absolute chronology in the Upper Euphrates and Transcaucasian region, in: Marro, Haputmann 2000: 73-93.
Dolukhanov, P., Timofeyev, V. 1972. Absoljutnaja xronologija neolita Evrazii (po dannym radiouglerodnogo metoda) /(Absolute chronology of the Neolithic of Eurasia (according to the radiocarbon method)/), in: Kolchina 1972: 28-78.
Dzhaparadize, O.M. 1961. K istorii gruzinskix plemen na rannej stadii medno-bronzovoj kul’tury (On the history of the Georgian tribes at the early stage of the Copper-Bronze Age culture). Tbilisi. Izdatel’stvo Tbilisskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta (in Georgian with a summary in Russian).
Eddy, J.A. 1977. Climate and the changing sun. Climate Change 1: 173-190.
Ehrich, R.W. (ed.) 1992. Chronologies in Old World Archaeology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Giemsch, L., Hansen, S. (eds) 2021. The Caucasus. Bridge between the Urban Centres in Mesopotamia and the Pontic Steppes in the 4th and 3rd Millennium BC. The Transfer of Knowledge and Technologies between East and West in the Bronze Age. Proceedings of the Caucasus Conference, Frankfurt am Main, November 28 – December 1, 2018 (Schriften des Archäologischen Museums Frankfurt 34). Frankfurt am Main: Verlag Schnell & Steiner GmbH.
Glumac, P., Anthony, D. 1992. Culture and environment in the Prehistoric Caucasus: The Neolithic through the Bronze Age, in: Ehrich 1992: 196-206.
Kalantaryan, A., Badalyan, R. (eds) 2003. Hin Hayastani mšakuyt‘ə 3 (The Ancient Culture of Armenia 3). Conference Papers Dedicated to the 70th Anniversary of Telemak Khachatryan. Yerevan: Mughni.
Kašuba, M., Reinhold, S., Piotrovskij, J.J. (eds) 2020. Der Kaukasus zwischen Osteuropa und Vorderem Orient in der Bronze- und Eisenzeit: Dialog der Kulturen, Kultur des Dialoges. Internationale Fachtagung für die Archäologie des Kaukasus und Humboldt-Kolleg (5.-8. Oktober 2015, Sankt Petersburg) (AIT 19). Berlin: Dietrich Reimer Verlag.
Kavtaradze, G. 1983. K xronologii époxi éneolita i bronzy Gruzii (On the Chronology of Eneolithic and Bronze Ages of Georgia ). Tbilisi: Metsniereba (in Russian).
Kavtaradze, G. 2012. On the importance of the Caucasian chronology for the foundation of the common Near Eastern – East European chronological system, in: Kiknadze 2012: 23-45.
Kavtaradze, G. 2017. An attempt at dating the starting point of the Kura-Araxes culture on the background of the ‘Uruk Cultural Phenomenon’, in: Rova, Tonussi 2017: 91-112.
Khanzadyan, E.V. 1967. Haykakan leṙnašxarhi mšakuyt‘ə m.t‘.a. III hazarmyakum (The Culture of Ancient Armenia in the III Millennium BC). Yerevan: Haykakan SSH GA hratarakč‘ut‘yun (in Armenian).
Kiguradze, T. 2000. The Chalcolithic – Early Bronze Age transition in the Eastern Caucasus, in: Marro, Hauptmann 2000: 321-328.
Kiguradze, T., Sagona, A. 2003. On the origins of the Kura-Araxes cultural complex, in: Smith, Rubinson 2003: 38-94.
Kiknadze, V. (ed.) 2012. The Proceedings of the Ivane Javakhishvili Institute of History and Ethnology XII-XIII: Dedicated to the 75th Year Anniversary of Professor Tamaz Beradze’s Birth. Tbilisi: Ivane Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University.
Kolchina, B. (ed.) 1972. Problemy absoljutnogo datirovanija v arxeologii (Problems of Absolute Dating in Archaeology). Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).
Kuftin, B.A. 1941. Arxeologičeskie raskopki v Trialeti (Archaeological Excavations in Trialeti). Tbilisi: Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk Gruzinscoj SSR (in Russian).
Kushnareva, K.K. 1997. The Southern Caucasus in Prehistory: Stages of Cultural and Socioeconomic Development from the Eight to the Second Millennium B.C. (University Museum Monograph 99). Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Museum.
Kushnareva, K.K., Chubinisvhili, T.N. 1970. Drevnie kul’tury Južnogo Kavkaza (V-III tys. do n. é.) /(The Ancient Cultures of the Southern Caucasus (V-III mill. BC)/). Leningrad: Nauka (in Russian).
Lucas, G. 2005. The Archaeology of Time. London: Routledge.
Lyonnet, B. 2014. The Early Bronze Age in Azerbaijan in the light of recent discoveries. Paléorient 40/2: 115-130.
Manning, S., Smith, A., Badalyan, R., Lindsay, I., Greene, A., Marshall, M. 2018. A new chronological model for the Bronze and Iron Age South Caucasus: Radiocarbon results from Project ArAGATS, Armenia. Antiquity 92(366): 1530-1551.
Manning, S., Lorentzen, B., Hart, J.P. 2021. Resolving indigenous village occupations and social history across the long century of European permanent settlement in northeastern North America: The Mohawk River Valley ∼ 1450-1635 CE. PLoS ONE 16(10): e0258555. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0258555
Marro, C. 2008. Late Chalcolithic ceramic cultures in the Anatolian Highlands, in: Rubinson, Sagona 2008: 9-37.
Marro, C., Bakhshaliyev, V., Berthon, R. 2014. On the genesis of the Kura-Araxes phenomenon: New evidence from Nakhchivan (Azerbaijan). Paléorient 40/2: 131-154.
Marro, C., Hauptmann, H. (eds) 2000. Chronologies des pays du Caucase et de l’Euphrate aux IVe-IIIe millénaires / From the Euphrates to the Caucasus: Chronologies for the 4th-3rd Millennium B.C. / Vom Euphrat in den Kaukasus: Vergleichende Chronologie des 4. und 3. Jahrtausends v. Chr. Actes du colloque d’Istanbul, 16-19 décembre 1998 (Varia Anatolica 11). Istanbul: Institut Français d’Études Anatoliennes-Georges Dumézil / Paris: De Boccard.
Martirosyan, A.A. 1964. Armenija v époxu bronzy i rannego železa (Armenia in the Bronze and Iron Ages). Yerevan: Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk Armjanskoj SSR (in Russian).
Munchaev, R.M. 1975. Kavkaz na zare bronzovogo veka: neolit, éneolit, rannjaja bronza (Caucasus at the Dawn of the Bronze Age: Neolithic, Eneolithic, Early Bronze Age). Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).
Palumbi, G. 2003. Red-Black Pottery: Eastern Anatolian and Transcaucasian relationships around the mid-fourth millennium B.C. ANES 40: 80-134.
Palumbi, G. 2008. The Red and Black: Social and Cultural Interaction between the Upper Euphrates and the Southern Caucasus Communities in the Fourth and Third Millennium B.C. Roma: Sapienza Università di Roma.
Palumbi, G. 2016. The Early Bronze Age of the Southern Caucasus, in: Oxford Handbooks Online DOI: 10.093/oxfordhb/9780199935413.013.14.
Palumbi, G., Chataigner, C. 2014. The Kura-Araxes Culture from the Caucasus to Iran, Anatolia and the Levant: Between unity and diversity. A synthesis. Paléorient 40/2: 247-260.
Passerini, A., Regev, L., Rova, E., Boaretto, E. 2016. New radiocarbon dates from the Kura-Araxes occupation at Aradetis Orgora, Georgia. Radiocarbon 58: 649-677.
Passerini, A., Rova, E., Boaretto, E. 2018. Chronology (and chronologies) of the Kura-Araxes culture in the Southern Caucasus: An integrative approach through Bayesian analysis. Origini 41: 81-138.
Renfew, C. 1973. Before Civilization: The Radiocarbon Revolution and Prehistoric Europe. New York: Knopf.
Rothman, M.S (ed.) 2001. Uruk Mesopotamia and its Neighbors: Cross Cultural Interactions in the Era of State Formation. Santa Fe – Oxford: School of American Research Press and James Currey.
Rothman, M.S 2021. Perspectives on the Kura-Araxes: The view from Shengavit, in: Avetisyan, Bobokhyan 2021: 52-68.
Rova, E. 2014. The Kura-Araxes Culture in the Shida-Kartli Region of Georgia: An overview. Paléorient 40/2: 45-67.
Rova, E. 2020. A unified terminology for the South-Caucasian ‘Early Bronze Age’: A worthy and achievable target?, in: Kašuba et al. 2020: 353-373.
Rova, E., Tonussi, M. (eds) 2017. At the Northern Frontier of Near Eastern Archaeology. Recent Research on Caucasia and Anatolia in the Bronze Age. Proceedings of the international Humboldt-Kolleg Venice, 9th-12th January, 2013 (Publications of the Georgian-Italian Shida Kartli Archaeological Project 2 / Subartu 38). Turnhout. Brepols.
Rubinson, K.S., Sagona, A. (eds) 2008. Ceramics in Transition: Chalcolithic Through Iron Age in the Highlands of the Southern Caucasus and Anatolia: 9-37 (ANES Supplement 27). Leuven – Paris – Dudley, MA: Peeters.
Sagona, A. 1984. The Caucasian Region in the Early Bronze Age (BAR International Series 214). Oxford: B.A.R.
Sagona, A. 2000. Sos Höyük and the Erzurum region in late prehistory: A provisional chronology for Northeast Anatolia, in: Marro, Hauptmann 2000: 329-373.
Sagona, A. (ed.) 2004. A View from the Highlands, Archaeological Studies in Honor of Charles Burney. Leuven: Peeters.
Sagona, A. 2014. Rethinking the Kura-Araxes genesis. Paléorient 40/2: 21-44.
Sagona, A. 2018. The Archaeology of the Caucasus: From Earliest Settlements to the Iron Age. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Schiffer, M.B. 1986. Radiocarbon dates and the ‘Old Wood’ problem: the case of the Hohokam chronology. JAS 13: 13-30.
Smith, A.T., Badalyan, R.S., and Avetisyan, P. 2009. The Archaeology and Geography of Ancient Transcaucasian Societies I: The Foundations of Research and Regional Survey in the Tsaghkahovit Plain, Armenia (OIP 134). Chicago: Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago.
Smith, A.T., Rubinson, K.S. (eds) 2003. Archaeology in the Borderlands. Investigations in Caucasia and Beyond (Cotsen Institute Monograph 47). Los Angeles: The Cotsen Institute of Archaeology at UCLA.
Summers, G. 2014. The Early Trans-Caucasian Culture in Iran: Perspectives and problems. Paléorient 40/2: 155-168.
Taylor, R.E., Stuiver, M., Reimer, P.J. 1996. Development and extension of the calibration of the radiocarbon time scale: archaeological applications. QSR 15: 655-668.
Tiratsyan, G.A. (ed.) 1996. Haykakan čartarapetut‘yan patmut‘yun, hator araǰin. Haykakan leṙnašxarhi čartarapetut‘yunə hnaguyn žamanakneric‘ minč‘ev m.t‘. 3-rd darə (History of Armenian Architecture, vol. I: The Architecture of Armenian Highlands from the Earliest Times to the 3rd Century AD). Yerevan: HH GAA ‘Gitut‘yun’ hratarakč‘ut‘yun.
Wilkinson, K.N., Gasparyan, N., Pinhasi, R., Avetisyan, P., Hovsepyan, R., Zardaryan, D., Areshian, G.E.,
Bar-Oz, G., Smith, A. 2012. Areni-1 Cave, Armenia: a Chalcolithic-Early Bronze Age settlement and ritual site in the Southern Caucasus. JFA 37/1: 20-33.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
