Evaluation of the Kura-Araxes migration: From a mono-factorial phantasm to a multi-dimensional phenomenon
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32028/ajnes.v16i1-2.1834Keywords:
Migration, resilience, translocality, diaspora, Kura-Araxes culture, Early Bronze AgeAbstract
Many scholars concerned with the Kura-Araxes cultural tradition take many aspects of this complex phenomenon for granted. In most publications, the expansion of this tradition across a vast area is treated like the movement of people from point A to B, or in the best case, as the waves of movement between these points. In most of them, migration is considered a direct reaction of people to population growth, lack of pasture lands, environmental stresses, and the Kura-Araxes as environmental or conflict refugees that flee a threat.
These perspectives in recent years terminated to some skeptics regarding considering the distribution of the Kura-Araxes material culture as a result of migration. On the other hand, turning to be once again a buzzword, ‘migration’ as an explanation, is considered anachronistic among some archaeologists. This article will reevaluate different scenarios related to the Kura-Araxes phenomenon to see where we stand and how we can overcome these shortcomings. It seems that the Kura-Araxes phenomenon at the current state of our understanding suffers different drawbacks at different levels. The migration scenario itself and the mechanism behind it are still vague, and the relationship between the core area and diaspora is rarely addressed. It is suggested that approaches such as ‘resilience theory’ and discussing the Kura-Araxes phenomenon and migration in the context of social resilience will be more promising for the topic at hand.
References
Assmann, J. 2011. Cultural Memory and Early Civilization: Writing, Remembrance, and Political Imagination. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Balossi Restelli, F. 2015. Hearth and home: Interpreting fire installations at Arslantepe, Eastern Turkey, from the fourth to the beginning of the second millennium BCE. Paléorient 41/1: 127-151.
Barnard, H., Wendrich, W. 2008. The Archaeology of Mobility: Old World and New World Nomadism. California: Coston Institute of Archaeology, University of California.
Batiuk, S.D. 2013. The fruits of migration: Understanding the ‘longue dureé’ and the socio-economic relations of the Early Transcaucasian Culture. JAA 32/4: 449-477.
Batmaz, A., Bedianashvili, G., Michalewicz, A., Robinson, A. (eds) 2018. Context and Connection. Essays on the Archaeology of the Ancient Near East in Honour of Antonio Sagona (OLA 268). Leuven: Peeters.
Beaudry, M.C, Parno, T.G. (eds) 2013. Archaeologies of Mobility and Movement. New York: Springer.
Bernbeck, R., Eberhardt, G., Pollock, S. (eds) 2022. Coming to Terms with the Future: Concepts of ‘Resilience’ for the Study of Pre-Modern Societies. Leiden: Sidestone Press.
Boyle, K., Renfrew, C., Levine, M. (eds) 2002. Ancient Interactions: East and West in Eurasia (McDonald Institute Monographs). Cambridge, UK: McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research.
Burmeister, S. 2000. Archaeology and migration: Approaches to an archaeological proof of migration. CA 41/4: 539-567.
Burmeister, S. 2013. Migration und Ethnizität: Zur Konzeptualisierung von Mobilität und Identität, in: Eggert, Veit 2013: 229-267.
Burmeister, S. 2017a. One step beyond migration Als Kulturelle Praxis. Distant Worlds Journal 3: 3-18.
Burmeister, S. 2017b. The archaeology of migration: What can and should it accomplish?, in: Meller et al. 2017: 57-68.
Burney, Ch.A., Lang, D.M. 1971. The Peoples of the Hills. Ancient Ararat and the Caucasus. London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson.
Cabana, G.S., Clark., J.J. 2011. Introduction. Migration in anthropology, where we stand, in: Cabana, Clark 2011: 3-15.
Cabana, G.S., Clark., J.J. (eds) 2011. Rethinking Anthropological Perspectives on Migration. Gainesville: University Press of Floride.
Çakırlar, C., Chahoud, J., Berthon, R., Pilaar Birch, S. (eds) 2018. Archaeozoology of the Near East XII. Proceeding of the 12th International Symposium of the ICAZ Archaeozoology of Southwest Asia and Adjacent Areas Working Group (ASWA), Groningen Institute of Archaeology, June 14-15 2015, University of Groningen, the Netherlands. Groningen: Barkhuis Publishing / University of Groningen.
Card, J.J. 2013. The Archaeology of Hybrid Material Culture. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press.
Clark, J.J., Huntley, D.L., Hill, J.B., Lyons, P.D. 2013. The Kayenta Diaspora and Salado Meta-identity in the Late Precontact US Southwest, in Card: 2013: 399-424.
Cohen, R. 1996. Theories of Migration. Brookfield: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Davoudi, H., Berthon, R., Mohaseb, F.A., Sheikhi, S., Abedi, A., Mashkour, M. 2018. Kura-Araxes exploitation of animal resources in northwestern Iran and Nakhchivan, in: Çakırlar et al. 2018: 91-108.
Davoudi, H., Sheikhi, Sh., Mohaseb, F.A., Radu, V., Darvish, J., Debue, K., Bailon, S., Fathi, H., Zalaghi, A., Maziar, S., Mashkour, M. in press. Human-animal interaction in the Araxes riverscape: Herding strategies and resource management based on Kohne Tepesi faunal inventory, in: Maziar, S. (ed.). Corridors of Interaction in a Dynamic Landscape: Socio-Cultural Prehistory in the Araxes River Basin (Ancient Near Eastern Studies Supplement Series). Leuven: Peeters.
Decaix, A., Berthon, R., Mohaseb, F.A., Tengberg, M. 2020. Toward a definition of the Kura-Araxes agropastoral systems, in: Meyer et al. 2020: 89-98.
van Dommelen, P. 2014. Moving on: Archaeological perspectives on mobility and migration, in: WA 46/4: 477-483.
Eggert, M.K.H., Veit, U. (eds) 2013. Theorie in Der Archäologie: Zur Jüngeren Diskussion in Deutschland. Münster: Waxmann Verlag GmbH.
Frangipane, M. 2015. Different types of multiethnic societies and different patterns of development and change in the prehistoric Near East. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 112/30: 9182-9189.
Frangipane, M., Di Nocera, G.M., Palumbi, G. 2005. L’interazione tra due universi socioculturali nella piana di Malatya (Turchia) tra IV e III millennio: dati archeologici e riconoscimento di identità. Origini 27: 123-170.
Frangipane, M., Palumbi, G. 2007. “Red-Black Ware, pastoralism, trade, and Anatolian-Transcaucasian interactions in the 4th-3rd Millennium BC, in: Lyonnet 2007: 233-256.
Gopnik, H., Rothman, M.S (eds) 2011. On the High Road. The History of Godin Tepe, Iran (Bibliotheca Iranica. Archaeology, Art and Architecture Series 1). Costa Mesa: Mazda Publishers / Toronto: The Royal Ontario Museum.
Greenberg, R., Ashkenazi, H., Berger, A., Iserlis, M., Paz, Y., Rotem, Y., Shimelmitz, R., Tan, M., Paz, S. 2017. The Circles Building (Granary) at Tel Bet Yerah (Khirbet El-Kerak): A new synthesis (excavations of 1945-1946, 2003-2015). BASOR 378: 163-202.
Greenberg, R., Palumbi, G. 2015. Corridors and colonies: Comparing fourth-third millennium BC interactions in southeast Anatolia and the Levant, in: Knapp, Van Dommelen 2015: 111-138.
Greenberg, R., Paz, S., Wengrow, D., Iserlis, M. 2012. Tel Bet Yerah: Hub of the Early Bronze Age Levant. NEA 75/2: 88-107.
Greenberg, R., Shimelmitz, R., Iserlis, M. 2014. New evidence for the Anatolian origins of ‘Khirbet Kerak Ware People’ at Tel Bet Yerah (Israel), ca. 2800 BC. Paléorient 40/2: 183-201.
Hauptmann, H. 2000. Zur Chronologie Des 3. Jahrtausends v. Chr. Am Oberen Euphrat Aufgrund Der Stratigraphie Des Norsuntepe, in: Marro, Hauptman 2000: 419-438.
Hauptman, H. 1982. Die Grabungen auf dem Norşun-Tepe, 1974-1975, in: Keban Project 1974–75 Activities (Middle East Technical University, Keban Project Publications I/7): 41-70. Ankara: Middle East Technical University.
Hoffner, H. (ed.) 1973. Orient and Occident: Essays Presented to Cyrus H. Gordon (AOAT 22). Neukirchen: Neukirchener Verlag.
Iserlis, M. 2009. Khirbet Kerak ware at Bet Yerah: Segregation and integration through technology. Tel Aviv 36/2: 181-195.
Iserlis, M., Greenberg, R., Badalyan, R., Goren, Y. 2010. Bet Yerah, Aparan III and Karnut I: Preliminary observations on Kura-Araxes homeland and diaspora ceramic technologies. TÜBA-AR 13: 245-262.
Ishoev, S., Greenberg, R. 2019. Khirbet Kerak Ware (Kura-Araxes) andirons at Tel Bet Yerah: Functional analysis and cultural context. Tel Aviv 46/1: 21-41.
Knapp, A.B., Van Dommelen, P. 2015. The Cambridge Prehistory of the Bronze and Iron Age Mediterranean. Cambridge historic online.
Kohl., Ph.L. 2007. The Making of Bronze Age Eurasia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kohl, Ph.L. 2009. Origins, homelands and migrations: Situating the Kura-Araxes Early Transcaucasian ‘Culture’ within the history of Bronze Age Eurasia. Tel Aviv 36/2: 241-265.
Kohl, Ph.L., Gadzhiev, G.M., Magomedov, R.G. 2002. Between the steppe and the sown: Cultural developments on the Caspian Littoral Plain of Southern Daghestan, Russia, 3600-1900 BC, in: Boyle et al. 2002: 113-128.
Koşay, H.Z. 1976. Keban Project, Pulur Excavations 1968-1970 (Orta Doğu Teknik Üniversitesi Keban Projesi Yayınları 3/1) Ankara: Orta Doğu Teknik Üniversitesi.
Leary, J. (ed.) 2014. Past Mobilities: Archaeological Approaches to Movement and Mobility. Surrey, England: Ashgate.
Lyonnet, B. (ed.) 2007. Les Cultures du Caucase (VIe-IIIe millénaires avant notre ère). Paris: CNRS Éditions.
Marro, C., Hauptmann, H. (eds) 2000. Chronologies des pays du Caucase et de l’Euphrate aux IVe-IIIe millénaires / From the Euphrates to the Caucasus: Chronologies for the 4th-3rd Millennium B.C. / Vom Euphrat in den Kaukasus: Vergleichende Chronologie des 4. und 3. Jahrtausends v. Chr. Actes du colloque d’Istanbul, 16-19 décembre 1998 (Varia Anatolica 11). Istanbul: Institut Français d’Études Anatoliennes-Georges Dumézil / Paris: De Boccard.
Maziar, S. 2019. Iran and the Kura-Araxes cultural tradition: So near and yet so far, in: Meyer et al. 51-74.
Maziar, S. 2021a. Resilience and migration: Time for changing the paradigm for archaeologists?. TRAVAS: Theorizing Resilience and Vulnerability in Ancient Studies. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5243255.
Maziar, S. 2021b. Geographical proximity and material culture: The interplay between Syunik and the southern part of the Araxes river basin in the 6th to the 3rd millennium BC. QI 579: 42-58.
Maziar, S. 2022. Resilience in practice: A view from the Kura-Araxes cultural tradition in Iran, in: Bernbeck et al. 2022: 101-116.
Maziar, S. in press (a). Cultural interaction during the 3rd millenium BCE in the southern part of Urmia Lake basin: Preliminary study of the Bronze Age pottery inventroy of Aliabad Bukan, nothwestern Iran.
Maziar, S. in press (b). Corridors of Interaction in a Dynamic Landscape: Socio-Cultural Prehistory in the Araxes River Basin (Ancient Near Eastern Studies Supplement Series). Leuven: Peeters.
Maziar, S., Erfurth. forthcoming. Setting values and building resilience in diaspora: Social memory and material manifestation of culture and Identity.
Meller, H., Daim, F., Krause, J., Risch, R. (eds) 2017. Migration und Integration von Der Urgeschichte Bis Zum Mittelalter / Migration and Integration from Prehistory to the Middle Ages (Tagungen des Landesmuseums für Vorgeschichte 17). Halle (Saale): Landesmuseums für Vorgeschichte.
Meyer, J.W., Vila, E., Mashkour, M., Casanova, M., Valle, R. (eds) 2020. The Iranian Plateau during the Bronze Age. Development of Urbanisation, Production and Trade. Lyon: Maison de l’Orient et de la Méditerranée – Jean Pouilloux.
Misztal, A.B. 2003. Theories of Social Remembering. Philadelphia: Open University Press.
Palumbi, G. 2008. The Red and Black: Social and Cultural Interaction Between the Upper Euphrates and Southern Caucasus Communities in the Fourth and Third Millennium BC. Roma: Sapienza Università di Roma, Dipartimento di scienze storiche archeologiche e antropologiche dell’Antichità.
Palumbi, G. 2016. The Early Bronze Age of the Southern Caucasus. Vol. 1. Oxford Handbooks Online. Oxford: Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199935413.013.14.
Palumbi, G. 2017. Push or pull factors? The Kura-Araxes ‘expansion’ from a different perspective: The Upper Euphrates Valley, in: Rova, Tonussi 2017: 113-132.
Palumbi, G., Alvaro, Co., Grifoni, C., Frangipane, M. 2017. A ‘communal’ building of the beginning of the Early Bronze Age at Arslantepe-Malatya (Turkey). Spatio-functional analysis and interpretation of the archaeological context. Paléorient 43/1: 89-123.
Palumbi, G., Chataigner, Ch. 2014. The Kura-Araxes Culture from the Caucasus to Iran, Anatolia and the Levant: Between unity and diversity. A synthesis. Paléorient 40/2: 247-260.
Passerini, A., Regev, L., Rova, E., Boaretto, E. 2016. New radiocarbon dates for the Kura-Araxes occupation at Aradetis Orgora, Georgia. Radiocarbon 58/3: 649-677.
Paz, S. 2009. A home away from home? The settlement of Early Transcaucasian migrants at Tel Bet Yerah. Tel Aviv 36/2: 196-217.
Pechurina, A. 2015. Material Cultures, Migrations, and Identities: What the Eye Cannot See. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Pecorella, P.E., Salvini, M. 1982. Researchers in the region between the Zagros and Urmia Lake. Persica 10: 1-35.
Philip, G. 1999. Complexity and diversity in the southern Levant during the third millennium BC: The evidence of Khirbet Kerak Ware. JMA 12: 26-57.
Ricci, A., D’Anna, M.B., Lawrence, D., Helwing, B., Aliyev, T. 2018. Human mobility and early sedentism: The Late Neolithic landscape of southern Azerbaijan. Antiquity 92(366): 1445-1461.
Rothman, M.S 2011. Migration and resettlement: Godin Period IV, in: Gopnik, Rothman 2011: 139-208.
Rothman, M.S 2014. Kura-Araxes Culture areas and the late 4th and early 3rd millenia BC pottery from Veli Sevin’s Surveys in Malatya and Elazığ, Turkey. Origini 36: 37-91.
Rothman, M.S 2016. Explaining the Kura-Araxes, in: Weber et al. 2016: 215-255.
Rothman, M.S 2018. Modelling the Kura-Araxes cultural tradition, in: Batmaz et al. 2018: 125-146.
Rova, E. 2014. The Kura-Araxes culture in the Shida Kartli region of Georgia: An overview. Paléorient 40/2: 47-69.
Rova, E., Tonussi, M. (eds) 2017. At the Northern Frontier of Near Eastern Archaeology. Recent Research on Caucasia and Anatolia in the Bronze Age. Proceedings of the international Humboldt-Kolleg Venice, January 9th-January12th, 2013 (Publications of the Georgian-Italian Shida Kartli Archaeological Project 2 / Subartu 38). Turnhout. Brepols.
Russell, L. 2012. Remembering places never visited: Connections and context in imagined and imaginary landscapes. International Journal of Historical Archaeology 16/2: 401-417.
Sagona, A. 1984. The Caucasian Region in the Early Bronze Age (BAR International Series 214). Oxford: B.A.R.
Sagona, A. 2014. Rethinking the Kura-Araxes genesis. Paléorient 40/2: 23-46.
Sagona, A. 2018. The Archaeology of the Caucasus: From Earliest Settlements to the Iron Age. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sagona, A., Zimansky, P. 2009. Ancient Turkey (Routledge World Archaeology). London – New York: Routledge.
Sakdapolrak, P., Naruchaikusol, S., Ober, K., Peth, S., Porst, L., Rockenbauch, T., Tolo, V. 2016. Migration in a changing climate. Towards a translocal social resilience approach. Die Erde: Journal of the Geographical Society of Berlin 147/2: 81-94.
Sakdapolrak, P., Promburom, P., Reif, A. 2014. Why successful in situ adaptation with environmental stress does not prevent people from migrating? Empirical evidence from Northern Thailand. Climate and Development 6/1: 38-45.
Samei, S., Alizadeh, K., Munro, N.D. 2019. Animal husbandry and food provisioning at the Kura-Araxes settlement of Köhne Shahar in Northwestern Iran. JAA 55: 1-24.
Smith, A.T. 2015. The Political Machine. Assembling Sovereignty in the Bronze Age Caucasus. Princeton – Oxford: Princeton University Press.
Smith, M.E. 2014. Peasant mobility, local migration and premodern urbanization. WA 46/4: 516-533.
Sterly, H., Sakdapolrak, P., Ober, K. 2016. Migration for human security? The contribution of translocality to social resilience. Georgetown Journal of Asian Affairs 3: 57-66.
Todd, I. 1973. Anatolia and the Khirbet Kerak problem, in: Hoffner 1973: 181-206.
Van Dommelen, P. 2014. Moving on: Archaeological perspectives on mobility and migration. WA 46/4: 477-483.
Weber, K.O., Hite, E., Khatchadourian, L., Smith, A.T. (eds) 2016. Fitful Histories and Unruly Publics: Rethinking Temporality and Community in Eurasian Archaeology. Leiden: Brill.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
