Bridging the Gap(s) between ‘European’, ‘Balkan’ and ‘Greek’ Archaeolog(ies)y
Keywords:
Balkans, Macedonia, Northern Greece, Colonialism, NationalismAbstract
The present paper examines the relationship between the terms ‘European’ and ‘Balkan’ archaeology and the way this is reflected on archaeology in Greece. More specifically, it discusses three main factors, most notably the seemingly sequential progress of archaeology, access to funding, and university rankings and publishing schemes all of which contribute to the perceived ‘backwardness’ of ‘Balkan’ archaeolog(ies)y when compared to ‘European’ ones. The chasm between these two, and the way this influences archaeological practice in Greece is then studied by comparing archaeology in Northern Greece, an area traditionally perceived as the link between the wider Balkans and Southern Greece, a region regarded as the cornerstone of the ‘Western’ world. The role of the foreign archaeological institutions and the Greek state in this divide is studied, arguing that the approaches of both towards Northern Greece are hindering the region from reaching its full archaeological potential. The paper concludes by providing some preliminary thoughts on future steps moving beyond dualisms and towards a more inclusive archaeology.
References
AEMTH 2023. Το Αρχαιολογικο Εργο Στη Μακεδονια Και Τη Θρακη 9 Mar 2023. https://www.aemth.gr/. Accessed 21 Apr 2023.
AMERICAN SCHOOL OF CLASSICAL STUDIES AT ATHENS - AFFILIATED PROJECTS 21 Apr 2023. https://www.ascsa.edu.gr/excavations/ascsa-affiliated-field-projects. Accessed 21 Apr 2023.
BABIĆ, S. 2014. Identity, Integration and Power Relations in the Study of the Iron Age, in: STODDARD, S. & POPA, C. (eds.), Fingerprinting the Iron Age: Integrating South-Eastern Europe into the Debate. Oxford: Oxbow: 295–302.
BABIĆ, S. 2015. Theory in Archaeology, in: WRIGHT, J.D. (ed.), International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2nd edition, Vol 1. Oxford: Elsevier: 899–904.
BABIĆ, S., KARL, R., MILOSAVLJEVIĆ, M., MIZOGUCHI, K., PALUDAN-MÜLLER, C., MURRAY, T. J., SCHLANGER, N. & VANZETTI, A. 2017. What is ‘European Archaeology’? What Should it be? European Journal of Archaeology 20: 4–35.
BARRETT, J. C. 2016. The new antiquarianism? Antiquity 90: 1681–1686.
BARRETT, J.C. 2021. Archaeology and its Discontents. Why Archaeology Matters. London: Routledge.
BRAJKOVIĆ. L. 2016. Higher Education in Western Balkans: Recent Trends and Challenges. International Higher Education 87: 27–29.
BRITISH SCHOOL AT ATHENS - RESEARCH 21 Apr 2023. https://www.bsa.ac.uk/research-2/. Accessed 21 Apr 2023.
CALOTYCHOS V. 2013. The Balkan Prospect: Identity, Culture, and Politics in Greece after 1989. New York: Palgrave.
CHRISTIDES, G. 2014. Greeks captivated by Alexander-era tomb at Amphipolis. British Broadcasting Corporation, 14 September 2014. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-29239529 Accessed 21 Apr 2023.
COLDSTREAM, N. 1977[2004]. Geometric Greece 900–700 BC. Second edition. London: Routledge.
DEUTSCHES ARCHÄOLOGISCHES INSTITUT - PROJEKTE. Accessed 21 Apr 2023. https://www.dainst.org/en/dai/meldungen. 21 Apr 2023.
DAMASKOS, D. & PLANTZOS, D. (eds.) 2008. Archaeology and the Hellenic Identity in the Twentieth Century. Athens: Benaki Museum.
DESPOINI, A. 2009. Gold Funerary Masks. Antike Kunst 52: 20–65.
ÉCOLE FRANÇAISE D'ATHÈNES - SITES DE FOUILLES 2023. https://www.efa.gr/en/recherche/sites-de-fouilles. Accessed 21 Apr 2023.
EUROPEAN COMMISSION-FUNDING AND TENDER OPPORTUNITIES 21 Apr 2023. https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/portal/screen/opportunities/horizon-dashboard. Accessed 21 Apr 2023.
FOTIADIS, M. 2001. Imagining Macedonia in Prehistory, ca. 1900-1930. Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology 14: 115–135.
GAVRANOVIĆ, M. 2018. No Group, no People? Archaeological Record and Creation of Groups in the Western Balkans, in: GIMATZIDIS, S., PIENIAZEK, M. & MANGALOGLU-VOTRUBA, S. (eds.), Archaeology across Frontiers and Borderlands. Vienna: Austrian Academy of Sciences Press: 427–447.
GAVRANOVIĆ, M., HEILMANN, D., KAPURAN, A. & VERČÍK, M. (eds.) 2020 Contacts and Relationships between the Balkans and Adjacent Regions in the Late Bronze / Iron Age (13th–5th Centuries BCE). Proceedings of the Conference held between 15–17 September, 2017 Institute of Archaeology, Belgrade. Rahden: Westf.
GIAMAKIS, C. 2022. The role of ethnicity in Greek Archaeology: A postcolonialist approach, in: DOĞAN, E, KAERCHER, K, ANTCZAK, O., ALDAY, C., PINTO LEITÃO PEREIRA, M., HASSLER, P., SHAKHMURADYAN, M., THOMPSON, P. & LIN, M. (eds.), Diversity in Archaeology. Proceedings of the Cambridge Annual Student Archaeology Conference 2020/21. Oxford: Archaeopress: 101–110.
GIANNAKOPOULOU, G. 2015. Modern Athens: Illuminating the ‘Shadows of the Ancestors’. Journal of Modern Greek Studies 33: 73–103.
GIMATZIDIS, S. & WENINGER, B. 2020. Radiocarbon dating the Greek Protogeometric and Geometric periods: The evidence of Sindos. PLoS ONE 15://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0232906.
GIMATZIDIS, S. 2018a. Claiming the Past, Conquering the Future: Archaeological Narratives in Northern Greece and the Central Balkans, in: GIMATZIDIS, S., PIENIAZEK, M. & MANGALOGLU-VOTRUBA, S. (eds.), Archaeology across Frontiers and Borderlands. Vienna: Austrian Academy of Sciences Press: 27–54.
GIMATZIDIS, S. 2018b. Northern Greece and the central Balkans, in: HASELGROVE, C., REBAY-SALISBURY, K. & WELLS, P. S. (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of the European Iron Age. Oxford: University Press.
GIMATZIDIS S. 2020. The economy of early Greek colonisation in the northern Aegean. Journal of Greek Archaeology 5: 243–262.
GIMATZIDIS S. 2022. Early Greek Colonisation in the Northern Aegean: A New Perspective from Mende, in: COLOMBI, C., PARISI, V., DALLY, O., GUGGISBERG, M. & PIRAS, G. (eds.), Comparing Greek Colonies: Mobility and Settlement Consolidation from Southern Italy to the Black Sea (8th – 6th Century BC). Berlin and Boston: De Gruyter: 52–67.
GORI, M. & IVANOVA, M. (eds.), 2017. Balkan Dialogues: Negotiating Identity between Prehistory and the Present. London: Routledge.
GORI, M. 2017. Stories From a Changing City. Heritage Places and Identity Performances in Former-Yugoslavia, in: VON HESBERG, H., KUNOW, J. & OTTEN, TH. (eds.), Stadt – Erinnerung –Denkmal. Positionen zur Validierung des kulturellen Gedächtnisses. Worms: 50–56.
GORI, M. 2018. Bronze Age and the embedded Macedonian Question, in, in: GIMATZIDIS, S., PIENIAZEK, M. & MANGALOGLU-VOTRUBA, S. (eds.), Archaeology across Frontiers and Borderlands. Vienna: Austrian Academy of Sciences Press: 391–440.
GORI, M., LERA, P., OIKONOMIDIS, S., PAPAYIANNIS, A. & TSONOS, A. 2017. Practicing Archaeology and researching present identities in no man's land: a view from the Tri-National Prespa Lake, in: GORI, M. & IVANOVA, M. (eds.), Balkan Dialogues: Negotiating Identity between Prehistory and the Present. London: Routledge: 254–270.
GOSDEN, C. 2005. Archaeology and Colonialism: Cultural Contact from 5000 BC to the Present. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press.
HALL, J.M. 2007[2014]. A History of the Archaic Greek World, ca. 1200-479 BCE, 2nd Edition. Malden and Oxford: Wiley Blackwell.
HAMILAKIS, Y. & YALOURI, E. 1996. Antiquities as Symbolic Capital in Modern Greek Society. Antiquity 70: 117–129.
HAMILAKIS, Y. 1996. Through the looking glass: nationalism, archaeology and the politics of identity. Antiquity 60: 975–978.
HAMILAKIS, Y. 2007. The Nation and Its Ruins: Antiquity, Archaeology and National Imagination in Greece. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
HAMILAKIS, Y. 2008. Decolonizing Greek Archaeology: Indigenous Archaeologies, Modernist Archaeology and the Postcolonial Critique, in: DAMASKOS, D. & PLANTZOS, D. (eds.), Archaeology and the Hellenic Identity in the Twentieth Century. Athens: Benaki Museum: 273–284.
HAMILAKIS, Y. 2009. Indigenous Hellenisms/Indigenous Modernities: Classical Antiquity, Materiality, and Modern Greek Society, in: G. BOYS-STONES, B. GRAZIOSI & PH. VASUNIA (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Hellenic Studies. Oxford: Oxford University Press: 19–31.
HAMILAKIS, Y. 2013. Double Colonization: The Story of the Excavations of the Athenian Agora (1924–1931). Hesperia: 153–177.
HAMILAKIS, Y. 2016. Some Debts Can Never be Repaid: The Archaeo-Politics of the Crisis. Journal of Modern Greek Studies 34: 27–64.
HARLOE, K., MOMIGLIANO, N & FARNOUX, A. (eds.), 2018. Hellenomania. Abingdon: Routledge.
HARMAN, G. & WITMORE, C. 2023. Objects Untimely: Object-Oriented Philosophy and Archaeology. Cambridge and Hoboken: Polity Press.
HEATH-STOUT, L. 2020. Who Writes about Archaeology? An Intersectional Study of Authorship in Archaeological Journals. American Antiquity 85: 407–426.
HEATH-STOUT, L. & HANNIGAN, E. 2020. Affording archaeology: How field school costs promote exclusivity. Advances in Archaeological Practice 82, 123–133.
HEATH-STOUT, L. E., ERNY, G. & NAKASSIS, D. 2023. Demographic dynamics of publishing in the American journal of Archaeology. American Journal of Archaeology 127, 151–165.
HERACLIDES, A. 2021. The Macedonian Question and the Macedonians. A History. London: Routledge.
HERZFELD, M. 1982. Ours Once More. Folklore, Ideology, and the Making of Modern Greece. Austin: Berghahn Books.
I Avgi 1 Mar 2022. https://www.avgi.gr/parapolitika/409244_i-ellada-anikei-stoys-ellines-itan-synthima-toy-kke-1945. Accessed 18 Apr 2023.
Ι Efimerida 6 Sep 2014. https://www.iefimerida.gr/news/169219. Accessed 21 Apr 2023.
KNODELL, A. 2021. Societies in transition in Early Greece. An Archaeological History. Oakland: California University Press.
KOLOVOS, E. & VIONIS, A. 2019. Ottoman Archaeology in Greece: A New Research Field. Archaeological Reports 65: 145–156.
KOTSAKIS, K. 1998. The Past is Ours: Images of Greek Macedonia, in: L. MESKELL (ed.), Archaeology Under Fire: Nationalism, Politics and Heritage in the Eastern Mediterranean and Middle East. London: Routledge: 44–67.
KOTSAKIS, K. 2017. Trenches, Borders and Boundaries. Prehistoric Research in Greek Macedonia, IN: SHAPLAND, A. & STEFANI, E. (eds.), Archaeology Behind the Battle Lines: The Macedonian Campaign (1915-19) and Its Legacy. London and New York: Routledge: 58–68.
KOTTARID,I A. 2014. The Macedonians and the Bottiaeans, in: ANDREAKI-VLAZAKI, M & BALASKA, A (eds.), The Greeks: Agamemnon to Alexander the Great. Athens: Μinistry of Culture and Sports: 208–223.
KOTTARIDI, A. 2016. Παλιές προκαταλήψεις και νέα ευρήματα: «Μακεδόνες ή Βοττιαίοι;», in GIANNOPOULOU, M & KALLINI, C (eds.), Τιμητικός τόμος για την Στέλλα Δρούγου ἠχάδιν Ι. Αθήνα: ΤΑΠΑ: 612–638.
KRISTIANSEN, K. 2014. Towards a New Paradigm? The Third Science Revolution and its Possible Consequences in Archaeology. Current Swedish Archaeology 22: 11–34.
Law No 3028/2002. Accessed on 21 Oct 2023.
https://www.culture.gov.gr/DocLib/g_1950.pdf
LEMOS, I. 2003. The Protogeometric Aegean: The Archaeology of the Late Eleventh and Tenth Centuries BC. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
MARAN, J. 2017. Later Balkan Prehistory: A transcultural Perspective, in: GORI, M. & IVANOVA, M. (eds.), Balkan Dialogues: Negotiating Identity between Prehistory and the Present. London: Routledge: 17–37.
MARAN, J. 2019. Not ‘cultures’, but culture! The need for a transcultural perspective in archaeology, in: ABU-ER-RUB, L., BROSIUS, CH., MEURER, S., PANAGIOTOPOULOS, D. & RICHTER, S. (eds.), Engaging Transculturality. Concepts, Key Terms, Case Studies. Abingdon: Routledge: 52–64.
MARAN, J. 2022. Archaeological Cultures, Fabricated Ethnicities and DNA Research: ‘Minoans’ and ‘Mycenaeans’ as Case Examples, in: DAVIDOVICH, U., YAHALOM-MACK, N. & МATSKEVICH, S. (eds.) Material, Method, and Meaning Papers in Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology in Honor of Ilan Sharon. Münster: Zaphon: 7–26.
MARÍN-AGUILERA, B. 2021. Ceci n’est pas un subalterne. A Comment on Indigenous Erasure in Ontology-Related Archaeologies. Archaeological Dialogues 28: 133–139.
MOSHENSKA, G. 2021. Degrowth and archaeological learning beyond the neo-liberal university. Archaeological Dialogues 28, 19-21.
MOUDOPOULOS-ATHANASIOU, F. 2020. The Ruins of Others: Cases from the Ottoman Heritage of Konitsa (NW Greece). Journal of Modern Greek Studies 38: 371–397.
MOUDOPOULOS-ATHANASIOU, F. 2022. The Early Modern Zagori of Northwest Greece: An Interdisciplinary Archaeological Inquiry Into a Montane Cultural Landscape. Leiden: Sidestone Press.
NIKLASSON, E. 2013. ‘And we would like to thank …’ The role of funding in Archaeology, in: KÄLLÉN, A. (ed.), Making cultural history. New Perspectives on Western Heritage. Lund: Nordic Academic Press: 151–161.
NIKLASSON, E. 2016. Funding matters: archaeology and the political economy of the past in the EU. Malmö: Holmbergs.
NOVAKOVIĆ, P. 2021. The History of Archaeology in the Western Balkans. Ljubljana: Ljubljana University Press.
OLSEN, B. 2010. In Defense of Things: Archaeology and the ontology of objects. Walnut Creek (CA): AltaMira.
OSBORNE, R. 1996 [2009]. Greece in the Making 1200-479 BC. Second Edition. London: Routledge.
PALAVESTRA A. & BABIĆ S. 2016. False Analogy: Transfer of Theories and Methods in Archaeology (The Case of Serbia). European Journal of Archaeology 19: 316–334.
PAPAKOSTA, K. 2017. Teaching ancient Greek history in Greek compulsory education: textual and ideological continuities and discontinuities. Paedagogica Historica 53: 477–489.
PLANTZOS, D. 2017. Amphipolitics: Archaeological Performance and Governmentality in Greece under the Crisis, in TZIOVAS, D. (ed.), Greece in Crisis. The Cultural Politics of Austerity: 65-84. London and New York: I.B.Tauris: 65–84.
Prime Minister’s Office 19 Dec 2022. https://www.primeminister.gr/2022/12/19/30914. Accessed 21 Apr 2023.
Proto Thema 12 Aug 2014. https://www.protothema.gr/politics/article/402026/tin-arhaia-amfipoli-episkeptetai-o-prothupourgos-adonis-samaras/. Accessed 21 Apr 2023.
QS 2023. https://www.topuniversities.com/university-rankings/university-subject-rankings/2023/archaeologyrankings. Accessed on 21 Oct 2023.
RIBEIRO, A. & GIAMAKIS, C. 2023. On Class and Elitism in Archaeology. Open Archaeology 9. https://doi.org/10.1515/opar-2022-0309
RIBEIRO, A. 2016. Archaeology will be just fine. Archaeological Dialogues 23: 146–151.
RIBEIRO, A. 2019. Science, Data, and Case-Studies under the Third Science Revolution: Some Theoretical Considerations. Current Swedish Archaeology 27: 115–132.
RIBEIRO, A. 2021. Revisiting the Chinese Room: Looking for Agency in a World Packed with Archaeological Things. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 31: 533–541.
RIBEIRO, A. 2022. Methodological Anarchism Against Interdisciplinary Archaeology, in: RIBEIRO, A. & ION, A. (eds.), Interdisciplinary Contentions in Archaeology. Forum Kritische Archäologie 11: 93–105.
SAKELLARIADI, A. 2008. Public Challenges and the Private Ways of State Archaeology: The Case of Greece. Conservation and Management of Archaeological Sites 10: 320-329.
SAKELLARIADI, A. 2011. Archaeology for the People? Greek Archaeology and its Public: An Analysis of the Socio-Political and Economic Role of Archaeology in Greece. Unpublished PhD Thesis. University College London. Available online: http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/35120.
SAKELLARIADI, A. 2021. Public Archaeology in Greece: A Review of the Current State of the Field. Ex Novo: Journal of Archaeology 6: 45–65.
SANDEL, M. J. 2021. The tyranny of merit: What’s become of the common good? London: Penguin.
SCHIERMEIER, Q. 2021. Horizon 2020 by the numbers: how €60 billion was divided up among Europe’s scientists. Nature pre-print (https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-03598-2).
SHANKS, M. 1996. The Classical Archaeology of Greece: Experiences of the Discipline. London: Routledge.
SHAPLAND, A. & STEFANI, E. (eds.), 2017. Archaeology Behind the Battle Lines: The Macedonian Campaign (1915–19) and its Legacy. London and New York: Routledge.
SHERRATT, E. 2011. Between Theory, Texts and Archaeology: Working with the shadows, in: DUISTERMAAT, K. & REGULSKI, I. (eds.), Intercultural Contacts in the Ancient Mediterranean. Proceedings of the International Conference at the Netherlands-Flemish Institute in Cairo, 25th-29th October 2008. Leuven: Peeters: 3–29.
SHOTT, M. J. 2022. Merit and placement in the American faculty hierarchy: Cumulative advantage in archaeology. Plos One 17.
SCIMAGO JOURNAL AND COUNTRY RANK 2022. https://www.scimagojr.com/journalrank.php?area=1200&category=1204. Accessed on 21 Oct 2023.
SKOULARIKI, A. 2020. Political Polarisation in Greece: The Prespa Agreement, Left/Right Antagonism and the Nationalism/Populism Nexus. South European Society and Politics 25: 411–439.
STEFANI, E., MEROUSIS, N. & DIMOULA, A. (eds.) 2014. A Century of Research in Prehistoric Macedonia 1912-2012.Thessaloniki: Archaeological Museum of Thessaloniki.
STEIRIS, G., MITRALEXIS, S, & ARABATZIS, G. (eds.) 2016. The Problem of Modern Greek Identity: From the Ecumene to the Nation-State. Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
TIMES HIGHER EDUCATION 2022. https://www.timeshighereducation.com/world-university-rankings/2023/subject-ranking/arts-and-humanities#!/length/25/subjects/3129/name/zagre/sort_by/rank/sort_order/asc/cols/stats. Accessed on 21 Oct 2023.
TODOROVA, M. 1997[2009]. Imagining the Balkans. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
TRIGGER, B.G. 1984. Alternative Archaeologies: Nationalist, Colonialist, Imperialist. Man 19: 355–370.
TRIGGER B.G. 1989 [2006]. A History of Archaeological Thought. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
TSIRTSONI, Z. 2017. Let’s stop speaking of ‘cultures’! Alternative means to assess historical developments in the prehistoric Balkans, in: GORI, M. & IVANOVA, M. (eds.), Balkan Dialogues: Negotiating Identity between Prehistory and the Present. London: Routledge: 64–84.
TZIOVAS, D. (ed.) 2014. Greece in Crisis. The Cultural Politics of Austerity: 65-84. London and New York: I.B.Tauris.
VOUTSAKI, S. & CARTLEDGE, P. (eds.), 2017. Ancient Monuments and Modern Identities. A Critical History of Archaeology in 19th and 20th Century Greece. London and New York: Routledge.
WHITLEY, J. 2001. The Archaeology of Ancient Greece. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
WITMORE, C. 2007. Symmetrical archaeology. Excerpts of a manifesto. World Archaeology 39: 546–562.
WITMORE. C. 2014. Archaeology and the new materialisms. Journal of Contemporary Archaeology 1: 203–224.
XYDOPOULOS I. K. 2006. Social and Economic Relations between Macedonians and the Other Greeks. Thessaloniki: Society For Macedonian Studies.
ZACHARIA K. 2008 (ed.) Hellenisms: Culture, Identity, and Ethnicity from Antiquity to Modernity. London: Routledge.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
