The function of desert kites: an analysis of hunting theory

Authors

  • Mariam Shakhmuradyan

Keywords:

Desert kites, function, hunting trap, theory, analysis

Abstract

The present paper discusses the function of large-scale prehistoric structures known as ‘desert kites’. Currently the most widespread view is that kites served as hunting traps for herds of wild ungulates, especially gazelles. This theory is mainly based on the ethnographic data as well as on the presence of several structural similarities between kites and game drives of other regions (North America, Scandinavia, Tibet). Other arguments as well in support of the hunting theory have been put forward, however direct evidence, confirming the mass-slaughter inside of the kites has yet to be found. In contrast to the hunting traps of other regions, where accumulations of stratified weapons and bones have been uncovered, no such evidence exists in the case of kites. Despite this fact, the hunting theory remains the most accepted and no attempts have been made to examine systematically the potential validity of this theory in light of available data. This paper aims to fill this gap.

References

Ababneh, M. 2005. Neue safaitische Inschriften und deren bildliche Darstellungen (SSB 6). Aachen.

Aharoni, I. 1946. Memories of a Hebrew Zoologist, Tel Aviv (in Hebrew).

Akkermans, P.M.M.G., Huigens H.O., Brüning M.L. 2014. A Landscape of Preservation: Late Prehistoric Settlement and Sequence in the Jebel Qurma Region, Northeastern Jordan. Levant 46/2, 186-205.

al Khasawneh, S., Murray, A., Thomsen, K., Abu Azizeh, W., Tarawneh, M. 2019. Dating a Near Eastern Desert Hunting Trap (Kite) Using Rock Surface Luminescence Dating. Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences 11/5: 2109-2119.

Amirov, S.S., Betts, A.,Yagodin, V.N. 2015. Mapping Ancient Hunting Installations on the Ustyurt Plateau: New Results from Remote Sensing Imagery. Paleorient 41/1, 199-219.

Andersen, R., Jordhøy, P., Bergstahl, J., Fossum, A., Olsen, J. 2006. Wild Reindeer Hunting as World Heritage. Unpublished Report for the Standing Committee for Power and the Environment, Norwegian Parliament.

Anell, B. 1969. Running Down and Driving of Game in North America (SEU 30). Uppsala.

Barge, O., Brochier, J.É., Karakhanyan A, 2015. Northernmost Kites? QI 395: 104-112.

Barge, O., Brochier J.É., Crassard R., 2015. Morphological Diversity and Regionalization of Kites in the Middle East and Central Asia. AAE 26/2: 162-176.

Barge, O., Brochier, J.É., Deom, J.-M., Sala, R., Karakhanyan, A., Avagyan, A., Plakhov, K. 2016. The ‘Desert Kites’ of the Ustyurt Plateau. QI 395: 113-132.

Barker, E.B.B. 1876. Syria and Egypt under the Last Five Sultans of Turkey: Being Experiences during Fifty Years of Mr. Consul-General Barker. London.

Bar-Oz, G., Nadel, D., Avner, U., Malkinson, D. 2011a. Mass Hunting Game Traps in the Southern Levant: the Negev and Arava ‘Desert Kites’. NEA 74: 208-215.

Bar-Oz, G., Zeder, M., Hole F. 2011b. Role of Mass-Kill Hunting Strategies in the Extirpation of Persian Gazelle (Gazella subgutturosa) in the Northern Levant. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United State of America 108: 7345-7350.

Bar-Oz, G., Nadel, D. 2013. Worldwide Large-Scale Trapping and Hunting of Ungulates in Past Societies. QI 297: 1-7.

Bar-Yosef, O. 1998. The Natufian Culture in the Levant, Threshold to the Origins of Agriculture. Evolutionary Anthropology 6/5: 159-177.

Barth, E.K. 1996. Fangstanlegg for rein, gammel virksomhet og tradisjon i Rondane (NINA-publikasjon: 124, NINA). Trondheim.

Behnstedt, P. 1994. Der arabische Dialekt von Soukne (Syrien), vol. 1. Wiesbaden.

Benedict, J.B. 2000. Game Drives of the Devil’s Thumb Pass Area, in: Cassells 2000: 18-94.

Benedict, J.B. 2005. Tundra Game Drives: an Arctic-Alpine Comparison. Arctic, Antarctic and Alpine Research 37: 425-434.

Betts, A.V.G. (ed.) 1998a. The Harra and the Hamad – Excavations and Surveys in Eastern Jordan, vol. 1. Sheffield.

Betts, A.V.G. 1998b. Dhuweila: Area Survey, in: Betts 1998a: 191-206.

Betts, A.V.G. 2014. A Response to Zeder, Bar-Oz, Rufolo, Hole (2013). QI 338: 125-127.

Betts, A.V.G, Helms, S. 1986. Rock Art in Eastern Jordan: ‘Kite’ Carvings? Paléorient 12/1: 67-72.

Betts, A.V.G., Burke, D. 2015. Desert Kites in Jordan: a New Appraisal. AAE 26: 74-94.

Borresen, J.A. 2002. A Faunal Analysis of the Frazier Site, an Agate Basin-Age Bison Kill-Butchery Site in Northeastern Colorado. Unpublished Master’s thesis, University of Tennessee, Knoxville.

Brink, J. 2005. Inukshuk: Caribou Drive Lanes on Southern Victoria Island, Nunavut, Canada. Arctic Anthropology 42 /1: 1-28.

Brink, J. 2008. Imagining Head-Smashed-In: Aboriginal Buffalo Hunting on the Northern Plains. Edmonton, Alberta.

Brochier, J.É., Barge, O., Karakhanyan, A., Kalantarian, I., Chambrade , M.-L., Magnin, F. 2014. Kites on the Margins: the Aragats Kites in Armenia. Paléorient 40/1: 25-53.

Brumley, J.H. 1984. The Laidlaw Site: An Aboriginal Antelope Trap from Southeastern Alberta, in: Burley 1984: 96-126.

Burckhardt, J.L. 1831. Notes on the Bedouins and Wahabys. London.

Burley, D. (ed.) 1984. Archaeological Survey of Alberta (Occasional Paper 23). Edmonton, Alberta.

Bull, J.W., Esipov, A. 2013. Ancient Techniques for Hunting Saïgas in Ustyurt: the Remains of Arrans. Saïga News 16: 18-19.

Cassells, E.S. 1995. Hunting the Open High Country: Prehistoric Game Driving in the Colorado Alpine Tundra. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University of Wisconsin, Madison.

Cassells, E.S. 2000. Coming into the Colorado High Country: the Archaeology of the Sawtooth Game Drive, in: Cassells 2000: 189-215.

Cassels, E.S. (ed.) 2000. This Land of Shining Mountains: Archaeological Studies in Colorado’s Indian Peaks Wilderness (Centre for Mountain Archeology, Ward, CO, Research Report 8). Ward, Colorado.

Çelik, B., Tolon, K. 2018. Desert Kites in Neolithic Period from Şanlıurfa. Karadeniz 37: 28-36.

Chahoud, J., Vila, E., Crassard, R. 2015. Archaeozoological Approach in Understanding the ‘Desert Kites’. AAE 26: 235-244.

Chahoud, J., Vila, E., Balasescu, A., Crassard, R. 2016. The Diversity of Late Pleistocene and Holocene Wild Ungulates and Kites Structures in Armenia. QI 395: 133-153.

Crawford, O.G.S. 1929. Note by Editor. Antiquity 3: 400-401.

Crassard, R., Barge, O., Bichot, C.-E., Brochier, J.É, Chahoud, J., Chambrade M.-L. et al. 2015. Addressing the Desert Kites Phenomenon and Its Global Range Through a Multi-proxy Approach. JAMT 22/4: 1093-1121.

Dalalyan, Hovsepyan, Babajanyan 2019. Proceedings of the Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography of Armenia 3: 21-35. Yerevan.

Dussaud, R. 1929. Les relevés du Capitaine Rees dans le désert de Syrie. Syria 10: 144-163.

Eddy, Wendorf 1999. An Archaeological Investigation of the Central Sinai, Egypt. Cairo.

Eissfeldt, O. 1966. Gabelhiirden im Ostjordanland. Kleine Schriften 3: 61-63.

Échallier, J., Braemer, F. 1995. Nature and Functions of the Desert Kites: New Data and Hypothesis. Paléorient 21: 35-63.

Eisenberg-Degen, D. 2010. A Hunting Scene from the Negev: the Depiction of a Desert Kite and Throwing Weapon. IEJ 60: 146-165.

Fowden, G. 1999. ‘Desert Kites’: Ethnography, Archaeology and Art, in: Humphrey 1999: 107-136.

Fox, J., Dorji, T. 2009. Traditional Hunting of Tibetan Antelope, Its Relation to Antelope Migration, and Its Rapid Transformation in the Western Chang Tang Nature Reserve. Arctic, Antarctic and Alpine Research 41/2: 204–211.

Gasparyan, B., Khechoyan, A., Bar-Oz, G., Malkinson, D., Nachmias, A., Nadel, D. 2013. The Northernmost Kites in South-West Asia: the Fringes of the Ararat Depression (Armenia), Project. Antiquity 087/336.

Gvirtzman, Sh., Gradus, B.-A. (eds) 1987. Human Geography. Tel Aviv (in Hebrew).

Harding, L. 1953. The Cairn of Hani. ADAJ 2: 8-56.

Harrison, D.L. 1968. The Mammals of Arabia. London.

Helms, S., Betts, A.V.G. 1987. The Desert ‘Kites’ of the Badiyat Esh-Sham and North Arabia. Paléorient 13/1: 41-67.

Hershkovitz, I., Ben-David, Y., Arensburg, B., Goren, A., Pinchasov, A. 1987. Rock Engravings in Southern Sinai, in: Gvirtzman, Gradus 1987: 605-616.

Hole, F. 2001. A Radiocarbon Chronology for the Middle Khabur, Syria. Iraq 63: 67-98.

Holt, A.L. 1923. The Future of the North Arabian Desert. The Geographical Journal 62/40: 259-268.

Holzer, A. 2002. Desert Kites in the Southern Negev, Their Dates and Function as Part of an Ancient Environmental System. Masters thesis, Tel Aviv University (in Hebrew).

Holzer, A., Avner, U., Porat, N., Horwitz, L.K. 2010. Desert Kites in the Negev Desert and Northeast Sinai: Their Function, Chronology and Ecology. Journal of Arid Environments 74: 806-817.

Horwitz, L.K., Tchernov, E., Ducos, P., Becker, C., Driesch, A.v.d., Martin, L., Garrard, A., 1999. Animal Domestication in the Southern Levant. Paléorient 25/2: 63-80.

Huber, T. 2005. Antelope Hunting in Northern Tibet: Cultural Adaptations to Animal Behaviour. Wildlife and Plants in Traditional and Modern Tibet: Conceptions, Exploitation and Conservation. Italy 33/1: 5-17.

Humphrey 1999. The Roman and Byzantine Near East: Some Recent Archaeological Research, vol. 2 (Journal of Roman Archaeology Supplementary Series 31). Cambridge.

Hutchinson, L.A. 1990. Archaeological Investigations of High Altitude Sites Near Monarch Pass. Colorado. Unpublished Master’s thesis, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO.

Ingold, T. 1980. Hunters, Pastoralists and Ranchers: Reindeer Economies and Their Transformations. Cambridge.

Jabbur, J.S., Conrad, L.I. 1995. The Bedouins and the Desert: Aspects of Nomad Life in the Arab East. New York.

Jordhøy, P., Støren Binns, K, Hoem, S. 2005. Gammel jakt- og fangstkultur som indikatorer for eldre tiders jaktorganisering, ressurspolitikk og trekkmønster hos rein i Dovretraktene (NINA Rapport 19). Trondheim.

Kempe, S., Al-Malabeh, A. 2010. Hunting Kites (‘Desert Kites’) and Associated Structures along the Eastern Rim of the Jordanian Harrat: a Geo-Archaeological Google Earth Images Survey. ZOrA 10/3: 46-86.

Kempe, S., Al-Malabeh, A. 2013. Desert Kites in Jordan and Saudi Arabia: Structure, Statistics and Function, a Google Earth Study. QI 297: 126-146.

Kennedy, D.L., Banks, R., Houghton, P. 2014. Kites in ‘Arabia’. Apple iBook.

Kennedy, D.L., Banks, R., Dalton, M. 2015. Kites in Saudi Arabia. AAE 26: 177-195.

Kirkbride, A.S. 1946. Desert ‘Kites’. JPOS 20: 1-5.

Kobusiewicz, M. 1999. Excavations at Sinai-10: the Kite Site, Romythi Locality, in: Eddy, Wendorf 1999: 173-180.

LaBelle, J.M., Pelton, S.R. 2013. Communal Hunting along the Continental Divide of Northern Colorado: Results from the Olson Game Drive (5BL147), USA. QI 297: 45-63.

Legge, A., Rowley-Conwy, P. 1987. Gazelle Killing in Stone Age Syria. Scientific American 257/2: 88-95.

Legge, A. J., Rowley-Conwy, P.A. 2000. The Exploitation of Animals, in: Moore et al. 2000: 423-471.

LeMaître, S., Van Berg, P.-L. 2008. The Engraved Rock Sites of Hemma (Syria). International Newsletter on Rock Art 52: 5-12.

MacDonald, M.C.A. 2005. Of Rock-art, ‘Desert Kites’ and Mesayid, in: Sedov, Smulyanskaya 2005: 332–345.

Maitland P. 1927. The ‘Works of the Old Men’ in Arabia. Antiquity 1: 197-203.

Malkinson, D., Bar-Oz, G, Gasparyan, B., Nachmias, A., Gershtein, E., Nadel, D. 2017. Seasonal Use of Corrals and Game Traps (Desert Kites) in Armenia. QI 464: 285-304.

Maraqten, M. 2015. Hunting in Pre-Islamic Arabia in Light of Them Epigraphic Evidence. AAE 26: 208–234.

Martin, L.A. 1998. The Faunal Remains from Dhuweila, in: Betts 1998a: 159-184.

Martin, L.A. 2000. Gazelle (Gazella spp.) Behavioural Ecology: Predicting Animal Behaviour for Prehistoric Environments in South-West Asia. Journal of Zoology 250: 13-30.

Meshel, Z. 1974. New Data about the ‘Desert Kites’. Tel Aviv 1: 129-143.

Moore, A.M.T., Hillman, G.C., Legge, A.J. 2000. Village on the Euphrates. Oxford.

Morandi Bonacossi, D., Iamoni, M. 2012. The Early History of the Western Palmyra Desert Region. The Change in the Settlement Patterns and the Adaptation of Subsistence Strategies to Encroaching Aridity: A First Assessment of the Desert kite and Tumulus Cultural Horizons. Syria 89: 31-58.

Musil, A. 1928. The Manners and Customs of the Rwala Beduins. New York.

Nadel, D., Bar-Oz, G., Avner, U., Boaretto, E. 2010. Walls, Ramps and Pits: the Structure of the Samar Desert Kites, Southern Negev, Israel. Antiquity 84: 976-992.

Nadel, D., Bar-Oz, G., Avner, U., Malkinson, D., Boaretto, E. 2013. Ramparts and Walls: Building Techniques of Kites in the Negev Highland. QI 297: 147-154.

Nadel, D., Bar-Oz, G., Malkinson, D., Spivak, P., Langgur, D., Porat, N., et al. 2015. New Insights into Desert Kites in Armenia: the Frignes of the Ararat Depression. AAE 26: 120-143.

Perevolotsky, A., Baharav, D. 1991. The Distribution of Desert Kites in Eastern Sinai and Sub-Regional Carrying Capacity: an Ecological Perspective. Journal of Arid Environments 20: 239-249.

Poidebard, A. 1928. Reconnaissance aérienne au Ledja et au Safa. Syria 9: 114-132.

Rees, L.W.B. 1929. The Transjordan Desert. Antiquity 3: 389-407.

Rosen, B., Perevolotsky, A. 1998. The Function of ‘Desert Kites’ - Hunting or Livestock Husbandry? Paléorient 24: 107-111.

Sala, R. 2011. The Complex of Terekty-Aulie, in: Erofeeva 2011: 557-569 (in Russian).

Sedov, A.V., Smulyanskaya, I.M. (eds) 2005. Arabia Vitalis. Moscow.

Shakhmuradyan, M. 2017. The Current State of Research on Desert Kites. AJNES 9/1-2: 17-47.

Shakhmuradyan, M. 2019. Anapati odaparukneri karuc‘vac‘k‘i ev jeveri k‘nnut‘yun (The Structure and Forms of Desert Kites), in: Dalalyan et al. 2019: 21-35 (in Armenian).

Teixeira, P. 1604. Travels of Pedro Teixeira (Broadway Travelers). London.

van Berg, P- L., Vander Linden, M., Lemaitre, S., Cauwe, S., Picalause, V. 2004. Desert Kites of the Hemma Plateau. Paleorient 30: 89-99.

Ward, W.H. 1910. The Seal Cylinders of Western Asia. Washington.

Whittenburg, A. 2017. Communal Hunting in the Colorado High Country: Archaeological Investigations of Three Game Drive Sites near Rollins Pass, Grand County, Colorado. Unpublished Master’s thesis, Department of Anthropology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado.

Woolley, C.L., Lawrence, Т.Е. 1914. The Wilderness of Zin (PEF III). London.

Wright, E. (ed.) 1961. The Bible and the Ancient Near East. Essays in Honor of W. F. Albright. London.

Wright, W. 1895. An Account of Palmyra and Zenobia with Travels and Adventures in Bashan and the Desert. London.

Yagodin, V.N. 1991. Strelovidnye planirovki Ustjurta (The Arrow–Shaped Structures of Ustyurt)/(Arxeologija Priaral’ja 5)/. Tashkent.

Yagodin, V.N., Amirov, S.S. 2014. Drevnie oxotničij sooruženija na plato Ustjurt (Ancient Hunting Structures on the Ustyurt Plateau). Saïga News 18: 18-20 (in Russian).

Zeder, M. 2011. The Origins of Agriculture in the Near East. CA 54(S4): S221-S235.

Zeder, M., Bar-Oz, G. 2014. A Response to Betts. QI 8(338): 128–131.

Zeder, M., Bar-Oz, G., Rufolo, S., Hole, F. 2013. New Perspectives on the Use of Kites in Mass-Kills of Levantine Gazelle: A View from Northeastern Syria. QA 05/297: 110-125.

Published

01/01/2020

How to Cite

Shakhmuradyan, M. (2020). The function of desert kites: an analysis of hunting theory. ARAMAZD: Armenian Journal of Near Eastern Studies, 14(1-2), 1–27. Retrieved from http://archaeopresspublishing.com/ojs/index.php/aramazd/article/view/969